Monash UniversityAcademic Board Meeting 5-2003Meeting No 5/2003 of the Academic Board was held on Wednesday, 1 October 2003, in the Council Room, Administration Building 3A, Clayton campus, between 2.15pm and 5.00pm. There were present: Professor A Lindsay (Chair), Drs G Acquaah-Gaisie, O Akindemowo, Professors R Alfredson, W Anderson, Mr C Avram, Dr H Ballis, Mr A Blakeman, Professor G Bouma, Associate Professor C Browne, Mr L Bull, Mr R Burnet, Professors K Burridge, B Caine, Dr J Choate, Professor M Clayton, Dr S Cockfield, Mr A De Bono, Associate Professor T Dix, Professor M Evans, Associate Professor D Garrioch, Professors R Gunstone, G Gupta, Mr B Harding, Mr C Hurley, Associate Professor J Hurst, Dr S Joseph, Associate Professor C Jubb, Professors L Kendall, F Klebaner, K Langfield-Smith, R Larkins, H Le Grand, Mr B Leung, Professor M Liddell, Associate Professor M Lindorff, Dr R Lisner, Ms J Lyneham, Professors B Mackenzie, A Markus, Dr G Martin, Associate Professor C Mingins, Professors K Murray, B Nelson, Dr R Nelson, Associate Professor P Nestor, Professor R Norris, Ms J Oates, Professors Tam, H Oppewal, Associate Professor M Page, Professors G Palmer, S Parker, JK Redmond, N Saunders, J Sheridan, M Skully, G Smith, J Smith, K Smith, Associate Professor I Snyder, Professor T Sridhar, P Steele, Dr K Stewart, Professor P Stewart, Ms K Styles, Professor OK Tam, Dr G Taylor, Dr S Ventura, Mr M Vincent, Dr E Villanueva, Professors P Von Nessen, J Walter, J Waincymer, G Webb, R Willis, S Willis, XL Zhao Apologies were received from: Associate Professor H Abachi, Professors C Adams, S Adeloju, J Anderson, Ms A Anumarlapudi, Professor J Bertram, Associate Professor K Blashki, Professor G Coleman, Dr B Cooke, Ms A Crook, Professor D De Kretser, Dr B Doecke, Professors R Doherty, G Egan, A Flitman, Mr P Handsworth, Ms C Harboe-Ree, Professors J Harris, B Hoffert, Dr M Iskander, Professor B Johnston, Ms S Joy, Professors M King, J Kulkarni, Dr C Lewis, Professors S McKemmish, K McLaren, Mrs J Mosse, Professors B Muddle, P Nagley, R Nation, Drs M Osborn, S Pickering, Mr A Pollock, Dr C Porter, Associate Professor P Reed, Professor B Srinivasan, Associate Professor J Teicher, Professors N Thomson, G Whyte Present by Invitation: Ms M Jackson Observers: Mr T Calder, Ms C Ho, Ms M King, Professors H P Leang, M Nair In Attendance: Ms K Wilson-Reid (Secretary) M I N U T E S* A PROCEDURAL MATTERS1 ARRANGEMENT OF AGENDA 1.1 Starring of Items Members noted that some items had been starred in the agenda for discussion. No further items were starred at the meeting. 1.2 Approval of Non-Starred Items The recommendations of the Steering Committee were adopted without discussion for all items other than those starred. 1.3 Confidential Items CThere were no confidential items on the agenda for this meeting. 2 MINUTES 2.1 Minutes of Academic Board Meeting 4/2003 held Wednesday, 20 August 2003 The Minutes of Academic Board Meeting 4/2003 were confirmed. * B STARRED ITEMS3 REPORT OF THE VICE-CHANCELLOR’S GROUP 3.1 Vice-Chancellor’s Address to the Academic Board The Chair, Professor A Lindsay, welcomed the new Vice-Chancellor, Professor R Larkins, to the Academic Board. The Vice-Chancellor addressed the Board and provided highlights of his experiences to date, his view of the Academic Board and its role and an outline of the issues and activities that would be a focus in the coming months. Professor Larkins informed members that he was honoured to take up the role. Following visits to a number of faculties and service units, the Vice-Chancellor noted a clear sense from staff and students of commitment to the university and its goals and a focus on the values underpinning research and teaching. He noted that Monash, a broad based university with significant experience and opportunities, was well placed to be a truly great international university. Professor Larkins highlighted the central role of the Academic Board as the quality control forum for academic and research standards and activity and the overarching body where policy development would be drawn together. The Vice-Chancellor noted that whilst it would be possible to retain the current model with Vice-Chancellor or nominee as Chair if preferred by the Board, an elected President of the Board, who would also retain an active academic role, would be best placed to provide an objective view representative of the active academics when advocating for academic standards in relevant forums. Some of the key issues and activities noted for the coming months included:
Professor Larkins advised the Board about the high calibre appointments of Professor Edwina Cornish as Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Research), Professor Edward Byrne as Dean of the Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences, and Professor Arie Freiberg as Dean, Faculty of Law. The Vice-Chancellor thanked Professor Gary Bouma for his significant efforts and achievements as Acting Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Research), and noted Professor Bouma’s generous offer to assist with transition at the commencement of Professor Cornish’s appointment. Members noted the address of the Vice-Chancellor, Professor R Larkins, to the Academic Board. 3.2 Chair’s Issues and Speculation Professor A Lindsay, Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic and Planning), informed members regarding current issues including:
Members noted advice from the Chair regarding current issues of interest to the Academic Board. 3.3 Monash in Europe 2010 RMO2002/0171 Documentation was circulated. (p 1-8) Professor S Parker, Deputy Vice-Chancellor, informed the Board about the strategic directions statement that would help to articulate the university’s plan and benefits from its international activities, and provide greater balance to Monash’s international strategy. Whilst engagement in Europe was primarily through the London and Prato Centres, this approach would take into account the total network of connections of Monash academics in Europe. Benefits of the proposed approach included enhancing Monash’s profile throughout Europe, encouraging prospective students from that region, access to new research funding sources via partnerships with European institutions, opportunities for students and staff to broaden their experience, the potential for collaboration and improved communication with alumni. Professor Parker advised that the opportunities for Monash were significant and at low cost to the university. It was estimated that by 2010 Monash would have activities dispersed across Europe that could be described as a "distributed campus". Discussion occurred about related issues including:
The Dean of the Faculty of Art and Design, Professor J Redmond, highlighted advantages to the university, its staff and students, of involvement in Europe, the intensity of the collegiate experience during participation in activities at the Monash centres, and the considerable academic and marketing benefits gained through Monash’s connections in that region. Noting the advice of the Deputy Vice-Chancellor, Professor S Parker, the Board noted and provided comment on the paper ‘Monash in Europe 2010 – A Strategic Directions Statement’. 3.4 Proposal for an Elected Chair of Academic Board RMO2002/1468 Documentation was circulated. (p 97-102) The Chair introduced this item noting the paper had been expanded from the version considered at the last meeting. Members noted the support of the Vice-Chancellor for the proposal in order to encourage free and frank debate at the Board through leadership by a member of the academic staff who was actively engaged in academic activity. Professor Larkins highlighted that development of a strong and positive relationship with the Academic Board was central to his role as Vice-Chancellor. However it was envisaged that leadership of the Board by an actively engaged academic would empower the academic community and strengthen its representation in relevant forums. This was particularly significant in a tertiary environment under greater pressure to safeguard academic standards. The Vice-Chancellor noted that the proposed 50% appointment would enable continuation of academic activity with support from a deputy president. Professor Lindsay noted that development of deputy positions would be staged following consideration of this proposal. Significant discussion ensued regarding aspects of the proposal including:
A number of members moved to support the proposal for an elected Chair of Academic Board. The Chair advised that a final proposal including election process would be brought to the next meeting. A request was received to consider a democratic process encouraging fulfilment of the role of Chair without emphasis on progression to an executive position. A vote was taken and the majority of members supported the proposal for an elected Chair. Professor Lindsay invited members to forward views about the process to his office for consideration during development of the final proposal. Following discussion of the ‘Proposal for an Elected Chair of Academic Board’, the Board endorsed the overarching principle of electing the Chair of the Academic Board, noting that a final proposal including the framework for election would be brought to the next meeting. Action/Information: Chair; Secretary 3.5 University-Wide Key Performance Indicators RMO1997/0325 Documentation was circulated. (p 83-96) Professor M Evans, Director, University Planning and Research, spoke to this item informing members about the process followed for development of KPIs and use of Go8 figures for benchmarking. Professor Evans highlighted the positive results shown in two areas of concern from the previous year. Outcomes from research benchmarking and the ability of the university to attract the top 5% of undergraduate applicants had improved. It was noted that research results at other Go8 institutions had also improved. The Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic and Planning), Professor A Lindsay, advised that indicator 4.1B on student satisfaction with graduate courses showed a stable result at Monash with an increasing rate at other institutions. He informed members that strategic measures would be initiated regarding use of the CEQ. Other measures might involve consideration of budget mechanisms. Members discussed the indicators presented and points were noted such as:
The Board noted the advice of Professor Evans and the ‘University-Wide Key Performance Indicators’ presented. 3.6 Research Matters RMO1998/0450 Documentation was circulated. (p 15-22) Refer also to the Report of the Committee of Associate Deans (Research). Professor G Bouma, Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Research and Development), informed the Board about the following research matters:
The Board noted the advice of the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Research and Development), Professor G Bouma, on research matters. 3.7 Question Time The Chair, Professor A Lindsay, introduced this item and informed members that questions about issues of interest to the Board may be raised under this item. The Chair noted that, where a question might require detailed information for a response, it would be appreciated if some prior notice (eg 24 hours before the meeting) could be given of the question. No questions were raised at this meeting. 3.8 Farewell to Professor Nick Saunders On behalf of the Board, Professor C Browne farewelled Professor Nick Saunders, Dean, Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences, who would shortly be retiring from the university. Members noted some of the Professor Saunders’ considerable achievements including Chair of the NH&MRC, a restructure of the Faculty to become Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences with a range of new health science courses offered and redevelopment of the medical curriculum. Professor Saunders noted the pleasure of working with the team in the faculty and thanked the Board and all those who had been supportive during his time as Dean. 4 ITEMS ORIGINATING FROM SECTION C C ITEMS FOR APPROVAL OR INFORMATION 5 MATTERS ARISING FROM THE MINUTES 6 MATTERS REFERRED TO ACADEMIC BOARD BY COUNCIL 7 REPORT OF THE UNIVERSITY ADMISSIONS COMMITTEE 7.1 Receipt of Report of Meeting 3/2003 RMO1998/1366 Documentation was circulated. (p 9-14) The Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 3/2003 of the University Admissions Committee, held on 28 August 2003. 7.2 Probation and Suspension for Under Performing Scholarship Holders Policy RMO1999/0762 The Board approved the following Policy on Probation and Suspension for Under Performing Scholarship Holders, as recommended by the Admissions Committee, that: The holders of centrally administered coursework scholarships will be assessed no less than annually, and within one or two weeks of the release of results in semester one or two, for continuance of their awards. Where a scholarship holder’s performance falls below the required average, the following procedure will be followed:
7.3 Entry to Faculty of Pharmacy Undergraduate Courses RMO1998/1685 The Board approved the recommendation that the Undergraduate Medical Admissions Test (UMAT) be used for undergraduate selection into the Bachelor of Pharmacy and Bachelor of Pharmacy/Bachelor of Commerce in the Faculty of Pharmacy, commencing in 2005. 7.4 Faculty of Pharmacy Rural Entry Scheme RMO1998/1685 Documentation was circulated. (p 13-14) The Board approved the recommendation that the Faculty of Pharmacy introduce a Rural Entry Scheme for the Bachelor of Pharmacy, as detailed in the documentation presented, commencing for the 2003 / 2004 selection period. Proceedings 8 REPORT OF THE COMMITTEE OF ASSOCIATE DEANS (RESEARCH) 8.1 Receipt of Report of Meetings 4/2003 and 5/2003 RMO1998/0450 Documentation was circulated. (p 15-22) The Board received and noted the Reports of Meetings 4/2003 and 5/2003 of the Committee of Associate Deans (Research), held on 12 June and 31 July 2003. Proceedings 9 REPORT OF THE EDUCATION COMMITTEE 9.1 Receipt of Report of Meeting 5/2003 RMO1998/0401 Documentation was circulated. (p 23-26) The Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 5/2003 of the Education Committee, held on 10 September 2003. 9.2 Student Academic & Administrative Grievance Procedures RMO1998/1776, RMO1998/1117, RMO1999/0078, RMO1999/1819, RMO2001/0719, RMO2003/0387, RMO2003/1033 Documentation was circulated. (p 27-34) In accordance with its terms of reference, the Education Committee approved amendments to the ‘Student Academic and Administrative Grievance Procedures’ that were submitted by the Deputy University Solicitor on behalf of faculties. Consultation occurred between the Deputy University Solicitor and the student rights area regarding the changes. The proposal that was approved and a version of the procedures with the changes highlighted in ‘track change’ mode (refer steps 4, 8 and 9) were attached for reference. The Board noted the amendments approved by the Education Committee to the 'Student Academic and Administrative Grievance Procedures'. 9.3 Process for Consultation with Student Rights Officers Regarding Proposals to Education Committee about Exclusion, Discipline and Grievance RMO1999/1817 Documentation is attached. (p 35-36) At its Meeting 4/2003, the Education Committee discussed the need for a standard process for consultation with the student rights officers prior to putting a proposal to the Education Committee for consideration. Relevant proposals included new or amended legislation, policy or procedures relating to student exclusion, discipline or grievance. At Meeting 5/2003 the Committee approved guidelines, prepared by the Deputy University Solicitor in consultation with the Secretary to the Committee, on the appropriate consultation process with the student rights officers to be followed for all future proposals to Education Committee involving these issues. The Board noted the standard process that has been approved for consultation with the student rights officers prior to putting a proposal to the Education Committee regarding student exclusion, discipline or grievance. Proceedings 10 REPORT OF THE RESEARCH GRADUATE SCHOOL COMMITTEE 10.1 Receipt of Report of Meetings 7/2003 and 8/2003 RMO1997/1156 Documentation is attached. (p 37-44) The Board received and noted the Report of Meetings 7/2003 and 8/2003 of the Research Graduate School Committee, held on 1 August and 5 September 2003. That Academic Board receive and note the Report of Meeting 7/2003 of the Research Graduate School Committee, held on 1 August 2003. Proceedings 11 REPORT OF THE BOARD OF THE FACULTY OF ART AND DESIGN 11.1 Receipt of Report of Meetings 1/2003 and 2/2003 RMO1998/1742 Documentation is attached. (p 45-46) The Board received and noted the Report of Meetings 1/2003 held on 11 April and Meeting 2/2003 held on 2 July 2003. 11.2 Academic Board Membership (Secretarial note: refer to item 16.1) Proceedings 12 REPORT OF THE BOARD OF THE FACULTY OF BUSINESS AND ECONOMICS 12.1 Receipt of Report of Meeting 4/2003 RMO1998/0456 Documentation was attached. (p 47-50) The Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 4/2003 of the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics, held on 13 August 2003. 12.2 Academic Board Membership RMO2002/1468 (Secretarial note: refer to item 16.1) Proceedings 13 REPORT OF THE BOARD OF THE FACULTY OF ENGINEERING 13.1 Receipt of Report of Meetings 2/2003, 3/2003 and 4/2003 RMO1998/1368 Documentation was attached. (p 51-52) The Board received and noted the Report of Meetings 2/2003, 3/2003 and 4/2003 of the Board of the Faculty of Engineering, held on 16 April, 11 June and the 27 August 2003. 13.2 Appointment of a Fellow of the Faculty RMO1998/2135 The Board noted the appointment by the Board of the Faculty of Engineering of Professor George Burns, as a Fellow of the Faculty for two years until 31 December 2005. Proceedings 14 REPORT OF THE BOARD OF THE FACULTY OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY 14.1 Receipt of Report of Meeting 4/2003 RMO1997/1159 Documentation was attached. (p 53-56) The Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 4/2003 of the Board of the Faculty of Information Technology, held on 3 September 2003. Proceedings 15 REPORT OF THE BOARD OF THE FACULTY OF MEDICINE, NURSING AND HEALTH SCIENCES 15.1 Receipt of Report of Meeting 5/2003 RMO1998/0708 Documentation was attached. (p 57-60) The Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 5/2003 of the Board of the Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences, held on 3 September 2003. 15.2 Award of Degrees PERSONNEL The Board endorsed for submission to Council the proposal of the Board of the Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences to award the following degrees:
15.3 Proposal to fill the position of Chair of Pharmacology PERSONNEL Documentation was attached. (p 61-66) The Board endorsed for submission to Council the proposal of the Board of the Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences to fill the position of Chair of Pharmacology. 15.4 Proposal to establish and fill the position of Professor/Director of Cardiology, Southern Clinical School RMO2002/0435 Documentation was attached. (p 67-72) The Board endorsed for submission to Council the proposal of the Board of the Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences to establish and fill the position of Professor/Director of Cardiology in conjunction with Southern Health. 15.5 Proposal to establish and fill the position of Professor/Director of General Surgery, Southern Clinical School RMO2002/0435 Documentation was attached. (p 73-80) The Board endorsed for submission to Council the proposal of the Board of the Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences to establish and fill the position of Professor/Director of General Surgery in conjunction with Peninsula Health. Proceedings 16 ACADEMIC BOARD MEMBERSHIP 16.1 Nominations from Faculty Boards to fill casual vacancies on Academic Board RMO2002/1468 The Board noted the following appointments made by Faculty Boards to fill casual professorial and non-professorial vacancies on Academic Board: Associate Professor Robert Nelson Art & Design until 30 June 2005 Professor Paul Von Nessen Business & Economics until 30 June 2004 16.2 Results for Election to Steering Committee of Academic Board RMO1997/1103 Documentation was attached. (p 81-82) The Board noted the results of the election held for one member of the Steering Committee of Academic Board from the academic staff (other than professors). 16.3 Casual vacancies for Alternate Membership of Steering Committee RMO1997/1103 Following the elections for membership of Steering Committee referred to in item 16.2, two casual vacancies arose for professorial alternate members. The following nominations were put forward by the Chair and the Steering Committee of Academic Board. The Board approved the nomination of Professor Kim Langfield-Smith and Professor Kate Burridge to fill casual vacancies for alternate membership of the Steering Committee, for a term of office until 31 August 2005: 17 ACADEMIC BOARD NOMINEES FOR PROFESSORIAL SELECTION COMMITTEES 17.1 Selection Committee for the Chair of Biotechnology PERSONNEL The Board nominated Professor Phillip Nagley to be the professorial representative of the Board on the Selection Committee for the Chair of Biotechnology (also the Head, School of Arts and Sciences), at Monash University Malaysia. 17.2 Selection Committee for the Dean, Faculty of Information Technology RMO1999/0565 The Board nominated Professor Phyllis Tharenou to be the professorial representative of the Board on the Selection Committee for the Dean of Information Technology. 17.3 Selection Committee for the Chair of Archival Systems, Faculty of Information Technology PERSONNEL The Board nominated Professor Kate Burridge to be the professorial representative of the Board on the Selection Committee for the Chair of Archival Systems, Faculty of Information Technology. 17.4 Selection Committee for the Chair in the School of Business PERSONNEL The Board nominated Professor Elizabeth Boros to be the professorial representative of the Board on the Selection Committee for the Chair in the School of Business at Monash University, Malaysia. 17.5 Selection Committee for the Professor of Communication, Faculty of Arts RMO1997/0553 The Board nominated Professor Margaret O’Connor to be the professorial representative of the Board on the Selection Committee for the Professor of Communication (School of Political and Social Enquiry), Faculty of Arts. 17.6 Selection Committee for the Chair of Health Economics, Faculty of Business and Economics PERSONNEL The Board nominated Professor John McNeil to be the professorial representative of the Board on the Selection Committee for the Chair of Health Economics, Faculty of Business and Economics. 17.7 Selection Committee for the Professor and Director, Learning and Teaching RMO1998/3032 The Board nominated Professor Phillip Steele to be the professorial representative of the Board on the Selection Committee for Professor and Director, Learning and Teaching. 18 ACADEMIC NOMINEE FOR THE CAR PARKING POLICY COMMITTEE RMO2002/1624 The Car Parking Policy Committee reports to the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Resources). The Board nominated Mr Barrie Harding as the representative of the Board on the Car Parking Policy Committee. ____________________________________________________________________________
|