ACADEMIC BOARD MEETING 3/2005

 

Minutes

 

 

Meeting No 3/2005 of the Academic Board was held on Wednesday, 25 May 2005, in the Council Chambers, first floor, building 3A, Clayton campus from 2:15 pm to 4:15 pm.

 

 

There were present:

 

Professor C Browne (President), Associate Professor H Abachi, Professor D Abramson, Ms J Adams, Professors S Adeloju, R Alfredson and W Anderson, Mr C Avram, Dr H Ballis, Mr J Beringer, Professor M Berndt, Dr S Blackburn, Professors K Burridge, E Bryne and P Cally, Associate Professor B Canny, Drs I Cartwright and D Casey, Professor M Clayton, Dr B Cooke, Professor E Cornish, Associate Professor A De Bono, Professor T Dingle, Associate Professor T Dix, Professor R Doherty, Associate Professor A Farley, Professor A Freiberg, Ms C Harboe-Ree, Dr M Hau, Ms C Holgate, Professors K Hourigan and O Hughes, Associate Professors J Hurst, B Jolly and S Joy, Professors M King, D Kirkpatrick, R Larkins, H Le Grand and M Liddell, Associate Professor M Lindorff, Drs R Lisner and J Lyneham, Professor D MacFarlane,  Dr L McCall, Professors S McKemmish, C McLean, A McMeekin, C Mingins, B Muddle, K Murray and P Nagley, Associate Professor P Nestor, Professors R Norris, M O’Connor, On Kit Tam and H Oppewal, Associate Professor M Page,  Professor G Palmer, Associate Professor S Petrovic-Lazarevic,  Professors M Pittard, D Poskitt and I Prince, Dr G Romeo, Associate Professor G Sanson, Professors J Sheridan, J Smith, T Sridhar, B Srinivasan and P Steele, Ms K Styles, Professors R Summers, J Teicher, B Tonge and M Vicziany, Mr M Vincent, Professors P Von Nessen and M Wallace, Mr D Watson, Professors GP Webb, R Weber, R Willis and S Willis.

 

Apologies were received from:

 

Drs G Acquaah-Gaisie and O Akindemowo, Professors J Bertram, B Caine and G Coleman, Ms A Crook, Professors D de Kretser, G Egan, J Godfrey and P Gronn, Ms K Jones, Professors J Kenway, K Langfield-Smith, A Lindsay, C Lipsig-Mumme and  B Mackenzie, Dr G Martin, Mr R Martin,  Professor R Nation, Drs R Nelson and M Osborn, Professor S Parker, Associate Professor C Porter, Professors R Nation and A Markus, Associate Professor P Reed, Dr K Stewart, Professors P Stewart and E Storey, Dr G Taylor, Professor N Thomson, Dr S Ventura, Professors J Wallace, J Walter and G Webb.

 

Invited guests:

 

Ms D Jackson, Mr P Marshall, Ms P Sanderson and Ms J Vero.

 

Observers:

 

Professor M Ariff, Professor Aun , Mr T Calder, Professor Chong, Associate Professor G Farr, Ms R Hinds,  Ms M King, Mr J Noonan and Ms S Rose.

 

In attendance:

 

Ms C Chatterton

 

*A       PROCEDURAL MATTERS

 

 

1          WELCOME

 

The Chair, Professor Chris Browne, welcomed those in attendance via teleconference from the Malaysia and South Africa campuses, observers, invited guests, Professor Catriona McLean, the new casual member, and Professor Tyrone Pretorius, PVC South Africa, as a new ex-officio member.

 

1.1              Starring of Items

 

Members noted that replacement pages ix & x of the agenda were tabled as well as an Addendum to the 2005 Academic Promotion Guidelines for item 4.6.  Items 23 to 30 were starred at the meeting and would be dealt with as a single item.

 

1.2       Approval of Non-Starred Items

 

The recommendations of the Steering Committee were adopted without discussion for all items other than those starred.

                       

1.3       Confidential Items                                                                                                       C      

 

There were no confidential items on the agenda at this meeting.

 

 

2          MINUTES

 

2.1               Minutes of Academic Board Meeting 2/2005 held Wednesday, 23 March 2005 RMO1997/0898    

 

The Minutes of Academic Board Meeting 2/2005, held on 23 March 2005, were confirmed.

 

 

*B       STARRED ITEMS

 

 

3                    PRESIDENT’S REPORT                                                                                            RMO2004/0809

           

Professor C Browne thanked members whose term of office ended on 30 June 2005.  The results of the elections will be available for the next meeting.

 

Board members were reminded that Council had delegated to the Vice-Chancellor the authority to approve the establishment and filling of all professorial positions.  Professor Browne clarified the procedures as follows:

·         Establishing and filling of new professorial positions – detailed proposals are to be submitted by faculty boards to the Office of the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic) who will then forward them to Human Resources and the Academic Board for endorsement and onward to the Vice-Chancellor for approval.

·         Filling of existing professorial positions – detailed proposals are to be submitted by faculty boards to the Office of the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic) who will then forward them to Human Resources and the Vice-Chancellor for approval.

Templates are being developed to assist faculties with submission of proposals. 

 

Professor Browne drew the attention of members to the university policy for:

·         the establishment of Centres, Departments  and Schools available at: http://www.adm.monash.edu.au/unisec/academicpolicies/policy/approval.html;   and

·         the establishment of research centres available at: http://www.monash.edu.au/research/statements/opmanual/fac362.html. 

 

The President noted that these policies have not been strictly adhered to in the past, and advised members that adherence to the policies will now be enforced by Academic Board. 

 

As Professor Alan Lindsay, Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic), will be on study leave from 1 July 2005 until his retirement, the responsibilities in the deputy vice-chancellor (academic) portfolio will be allocated to the senior deputy vice-chancellor.  It is proposed that all references to the ‘Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic)’ or the ‘Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic and Planning)’ in academic policies, memberships and documents, will read as ‘Senior Deputy Vice-Chancellor’, until other arrangements are put in place.  Professor Lindsay was unable to attend this meeting due to prior commitments but has indicated that he intends to attend a future meeting of the Board, at which time a formal thanks for services to the Board will be accorded.

 

Academic Board noted the advice of the President.

 

Academic Board endorsed, for transmission to Council for approval, the resolution that from 1 July 2005 all documents, academic policies and memberships with reference to the ‘Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic)’ or the ‘Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic and Planning)’, should read ‘Senior Deputy Vice-Chancellor’.

 

 

4                    REPORT OF THE VICE-CHANCELLOR’S GROUP                                                                     

 

4.1              Vice-Chancellor’s Report                                                                                            

                                                                                                                                                    

A report was attached. (p 159-160)

 

Professor R Larkins spoke to his report and updated the Board on the following issues:

 

·         Voluntary Student Unionism.  In spite of lobbying of members of Parliament, there seems to be no room for negotiation.  The government is aware of the separate role of amenities fees.  A number of university chancellors had written to the Prime Minister and had arranged a meeting with him.  At the internal level, meetings had been held with student organisations and it is anticipated that the university will need an amount of approximately $4.75 million to fund activities considered essential.

·         HEWRRs. Monash is required to offer all new staff, including casual appointments, individually certified Australian Workplace Agreements (AWAs) as well as comply with a range of requirements in order to receive the 5% increase in the Commonwealth Grants Scheme (CGS) in 2006. AWAs should be flexible, simple and not detailed. More details will be available in June.  At present Monash does not have a mechanism to offer AWAs.  Monash would continue to work with the Unions to achieve the best outcome but cannot afford to forego the 5% increase in CGS.

·         Indexation. A review of indexation was undertaken by DEST in cooperation with the Department of Finance and Administration.  After considering the findings of the report, the government concluded that there was not a strong case for change to the current indexation arrangements justified by the apparent strong financial health of the sector.  Since 1996 indexation had averaged about 1.5% to 2%, whereas costs had been increasing by 6%.  The decrease in international student demand and the ageing infrastructure did not seem to have been considered. 

·         Senior Appointments.  Mr Tony Pollock had accepted the appointment of CEO of IDP.  The Vice-President International position at Monash would be reconfigured to a Deputy Vice-Chancellor (International) and would include an international academic aspect with oversight of the academic development of overseas campuses as well as the linkages under development.  The new position of Vice-President (Finance) had been offered and accepted and an announcement would be made on 1 July.

 

In response to a query about having to offer AWAs to visiting lecturers, Professor Larkins stated that reimbursement of costs would not require AWAs but payment of a wage or fee would require an AWA. A change in the procedure for appointing visitors to the university is under consideration.

 

Academic Board received the report and noted the advice of the Vice-Chancellor.

                                               

4.2              Gippsland Campus Urban Plan                                                                 RMO2001/0662

 

Ms P Sanderson, Chief Executive Officer, Monash Property Management, spoke to a presentation (Attachment 1), which is a draft document requiring further consultation.

 

Stage 1 of the plan includes key initiatives to indicate a sense of arrival at the roundabout, boulevard landscaping and a central administrative hub.  Stage 2 includes a student heart, a pedestrian link, a sports pavilion and a library extension.  New student housing, car parking and an education and business partnership precinct would comprise Stage 3.  Provision is also available for expansion of teaching and research facilities.  Ms Sanderson informed the Board that this was a 20-30 year plan that depended on growth in student numbers at the campus and available funding.

 

Noting that the replacement of the Binishell was a high priority, there was a suggestion that some external funding for replacement of the Binishell could be sought as there are two other users on the campus.

 

In response to a query about the possibility of student accommodation in Traralgon along with a bus service to Churchill, Ms Sanderson stated that this had been a recent suggestion which was being explored by the Pro Vice-Chancellor Gippsland, but pointed out that such a move would take students away from the campus.

 

Academic Board received the presentation and noted the advice from Ms Sanderson, Chief Executive Officer, Monash Property Management.

                       

4.3              Peninsula Campus Urban Plan                                                                  RMO2000/1088

 

Ms P Sanderson, Chief Executive Officer, Monash Property Management, spoke to a presentation (Attachment 2), which is a draft document requiring further consultation.

 

Stage 1 included a Health and Well Being Centre, a multi-deck carpark, redevelopment of the main campus entry and a new sports pavilion.  The Health and Well Being Centre proposal included a 50m indoor pool, basketball courts, a café, a gymnasium and gymnastics area.  Stage 2 would comprise the demolition of building B and erection of two new buildings.  Stage 3 included a new administration precinct, a student heart, a pedestrian spine and a new maintenance services building.  Stage 4 included a new ring road, multi-deck car park, new security building, refurbishment of building C, redevelopment of Straun House, tennis courts and landscaping.

 

In response to a query about funding for sporting facilities which would normally be funded from amenities fees, Ms Sanderson reported that discussions were being held with local and state governments and it is anticipated that a sizeable portion would be funded externally.  Professor P Steele, Peninsula Campus Director, added that a range of models were being explored without major capital funding from the university.

 

Responding to a statement that the proposed ring road seemed to be cutting off part of the campus, Ms Sanderson responded that the plan had to be worked around the flood plain.

 

The Vice-Chancellor congratulated Ms Sanderson and her team for the work done on the five campus urban plans.  A proposal to sequence planning of what would be needed for the next 20-30 years had been presented to VCG and would be forwarded to committees and the Board in due course.

 

Academic Board received the presentation and noted the advice from Ms Sanderson, Chief Executive Officer, Monash Property Management.

 

4.4       Establishment of the e-Research @ Monash Centre                                              

 

A proposal was attached. (p 129-144) 

 

Professor E Cornish, Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Research), addressed the Board with background to the proposal and stated that the centre was modelled on centres established in the UK.  The centre would be a partnership between IT researchers and IT services to provide a capacity to support high end users and to link the campuses together to create virtual research communities.  It would provide a defining edge to the research that could be conducted at Monash.  The centre would provide leadership and advocacy in e-research to government agencies, scientific organisations, funding bodies, research teams and faculties. 

 

Responding to a query as to whether the proposed centre would be similar to the large consolidated e-research institutions in the UK, Professor Cornish stated that the UK had a large amount of funding to build infrastructure but it is proposed that this centre would be a partnership between IT researchers and IT services.

 

In response to a comment about the lifespan of the centre and the name of the centre, Professor Cornish responded that a number of the services provided might move to IT services and guide Monash investment in IT services.  Concern was expressed about the form of the name ‘E-Research @ Monash Centre’ and Professor Cornish offered to take advice from the Marketing section.  The Librarian stated that DEST and MCEETYA had just established an e-research committee and one of its goals was to phase out the use of the term “e-research” in a few years time.

 

Responding to a query on the amount of seed funding that would be available for cross campus initiatives, Professor Cornish stated that this would be determined once a director had been appointed.

 

Academic Board noted the advice of Professor Cornish, Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Research), and endorsed, for transmission to Council for approval, the proposal to establish the e-Research @ Monash Centre.

 

 

 

4.5        Quality Matters

 

4.5.1  Quality Audit                                                                                      RMO2001/1011      

 

A report was attached. (p. 1-6)

 

Professor R Larkins, Vice-Chancellor, addressed the Board in the absence of Professor S Parker and drew attention to the AUQA visit in September 2006.  This would be preceded by a visit to South Africa and, if necessary, to Malaysia.  The outline of the portfolio had been approved by AUQA.  The preparation of the portfolio is a substantial task and the audit process is extensive and a demanding one for the university being audited.  The intention of Monash is to use the audit constructively, not just for compliance.  The audit would be complimentary to the Research Quality Framework and Learning and Teaching Fund.  The AUQA audit focuses on process rather than outcomes.  The Steering Committee had suggested that the AUQA audit become a standing item on the Board agenda until the audit is completed.   

 

Academic Board received the report, noted the advice of Professor Larkins, Vice-Chancellor, and approved the inclusion of the AUQA Audit as a standing item on the Board agenda until the audit was completed.

 

4.6               Academic Promotion 2005                                                                         RMO1998/3177

 

A document and addendum was attached. (p 7-18 + addendum)                                   

                                                                                                                                                    

Mr P Marshall, Divisional Director, Student and Staff Services Division, informed the Board that the Professorial Appointments Review report had been endorsed at meeting 4/2004 and the Academic Promotion Guidelines 2005 comprised the procedural update.  The guidelines had been edited to assist the clarity of the document with significant changes as under:

·         Addition to the provision for promotion to professor;

·         Recommendations from the Vice-Chancellor’s Task Force on the Advancement of Women;

·         Item 2.7 was changed to ‘Relevant Circumstances’ from ‘Special Circumstances’; and

·         Item 1.2 was changed to enable candidates not at the top of the scale to apply if they meet the criteria at item 2.1.

 

After consultation with the NTEU, the addendum that was tabled is proposed to be added to the guidelines.

 

In response to a query about teaching not being included under item 2.8, Special Cases for Promotion, whereas leadership and research had been given prominence, Mr Marshall advised that teaching had not been reconsidered by the working party that reviewed the policy, and the guidelines set out were consistent with the policy.  The Chair clarified that the policy did not lessen the value of teaching, rather the working party felt that the issues of leadership and research needed proper recognition at this stage of promotion.

 

Under item 2.3, Promotion to Lecturer and Senior Lecturer, it was suggested that development of educational resources for use by others be included as an additional dot point.

 

A member commented that the guidelines were uninstructive in regard to the re-hearing of unsuccessful applicants and suggested that there should be a specific sub-heading with expanded guidelines to assist unsuccessful applicants and those who counsel them.  The Chair suggested that this be noted and considered when the guidelines were updated for the following year.

 

Academic Board noted the advice of Mr Marshall, Divisional Director, Student and Staff Services Division, and approved the Academic Promotion 2005 Guidelines for candidates along with the addendum, as well as the addition of the following dot point under item 2.3 Promotion to Lecturer and Senior Lecturer:

·         development of educational resources for use by others;

 

and the following dot point should read as:

·         involvement in internal processes to promote high quality teaching and learning, such as development of educational resources and presentation of case studies, workshops, papers and reports at department, school, faculty or university level.

 

Academic Board noted the suggestion that the re-hearing of unsuccessful applicants would be considered as a sub-heading in the editing of the guidelines for 2006.

 

Academic Board commended the Senior Deputy Vice-Chancellor and members of the working party for simplifying the guidelines.

 

4.7               Development of the Learning and Teaching Plan                                  RMO2002/1564      

                                                                                                                                                    

A schedule was attached. (p 29-30) 

 

Professor D Kirkpatrick, Director Learning and Teaching, informed the Board that the current Learning and Teaching Plan ran from 2003-2005.  A Scoping Steering Group would guide the development of the new plan.  It is intended that the new plan would build on the existing one, advance some of the priorities and introduce new priorities identified in Monash 2025 and the Planning Conference held in February 2005.  The plan would also build on the Values for High-Quality Teaching and Learning Policy and would operate at a level that would allow faculties to customise activities.  A website would be set up with exposure drafts to allow feedback from staff and students.  A one and a half day workshop had been scheduled for the end of June which would include representation from the Malaysia and South Africa campuses.

 

Professor R Larkins, Vice-Chancellor, advised that feedback received on Monash 2025 was that research was being given more prominence ahead of teaching and learning.  He stressed that Monash must be excellent at both teaching and research and one was not more important than the other.

 

In response to a question from the Berwick and Peninsula Campus Director regarding the integration of cross-campus teaching into the Learning and Teaching Plan, Professor Kirkpatrick stated that the plan has not yet been written and welcomed input from Professor Steele at the workshop in June.

 

Academic Board approved the schedule and noted the advice of Professor Kirkpatrick, Director, Learning and Teaching, and Professor Larkins, Vice-Chancellor.

   

4.8               Student Load Report 2005                                                                         RMO2001/1605

                                                                                                                                                    

A report was attached. (p 161-164).

 

Ms J Vero, Planning Advisor, University Planning and Research, informed the Board that this report followed on from the report on undergraduate admissions presented to meeting 1/2005.  This report provided data on estimated student load to the end of 2005.  Mrs D Jackson, Load Planning Coordinator, University Planning and Research, advised that the DEST funded coursework load was expected to be slightly under target.  Under the Higher Education Support Act (HESA), this target had to be met before the end of the year and, if necessary, fee places would be converted to Commonwealth supported places.  Australian fee-paying student load was expected to be over target while international student load was expected to be below target.  Vigorous activity had been taking place to increase the amount of international students in the mid-year intake. Ms Jackson also informed the Board that the ‘Stats-Online’ system would be replaced by a new system which would allow faculties to monitor trends.   Subsequent reports to Academic Board would contain trend analyses.

 

The Board discussed the tolerance of 1% in the target and considered that the best outcome would be to achieve a load of -1%. 

 

Ms Jackson confirmed that the new system would be able to identify terminating students.

 

Academic Board received the report and noted the advice of Ms Vero, Planning Advisor, and Mrs Jackson, Load Planning Coordinator, University Planning and Research.

 

(Secretarial Note:   There is a funding target that goes with the load target.  The tolerance for the funding target is -1.0% to 0, i.e., if Monash is more than 1% below the funding target the University will be penalised. There is provision in the legislation for funding equal to 101% of the agreed funding amount.  However, as was pointed out by DEST representatives at their meeting on 20 April 2005, there was no guarantee that the additional funding would be paid and it was not available for 2005.  [See section 33-25, HESA]

 

HESA 36-30 Providers to fill Commonwealth supported places before accepting other enrolments. A higher education provider must fill its allocated Commonwealth supported places for the year in order to be able to offer students fee-paying places, i.e. if a person is to be enrolled in a unit of study that is covered by the person's Student Learning Entitlement, and the provider has not already filled all of its allocated Commonwealth supported places, the provider must enrol the person in the unit as a Commonwealth supported student.)

 

4.9               Question Time

 

4.9.1  Services for International Students                                                                 

 

A Board member raised the issue of access to health and pharmaceutical services for international students and the poor living conditions of students living in private rental accommodation.

 

The Vice-Chancellor advised that at meetings with groups of international students, a number of these issues had arisen, including the issue of international students not being eligible for transport concession cards.

 

The Chair indicated that Monash had recently completed an International Self-Review process which included a large amount of engagement with students.  The report of the International Self-Review was scheduled to proceed to the Senior Management Committee on 7 June 2005 and would be presented to a subsequent meeting of Academic Board.

 

Academic Board noted that the report of the International Self-Review would be presented to a future meeting of the Board.

 

4.9.2  ‘Reselling’ of degrees.                                                                                      

 

A Board member referred to an article in the ‘Financial Review’ dated 23 May 2005, entitled “Here comes the US vanguard” which stated that US company Kaplan had acquired the Asia Pacific Management Institute (APMI) with whom Monash had a partnership contract for three programs.  The article went on to state that APMI “resells” degrees.  Monash was mentioned in the article as one of APMI partner universities.  The Board member queried the steps Monash was taking to ensure that the Monash brand was not a traded commodity.

 

The Vice-Chancellor responded that no negotiations had taken place with Kaplan and reselling would be a contradiction of Monash 2025.  The Monash contract with APMI did not permit on-selling of the degrees.

 

It was suggested that Monash should seek an apology from the publication if the article is inaccurate.

 

Academic Board noted with concern the allegations made in the article.

 

 

5          MATTERS ARISING FROM THE MINUTES

 

 

6          ITEMS ORIGINATING FROM SECTION C

 

    *6.1      Nominations for the Award of Honorary Degrees                                    RMO2003/085                  

 

This item originated at item 11.2 of this agenda. Professor R Larkins, Vice-Chancellor read the names of the eight candidates for the award of Honorary Degrees in 2005.  Four had already been conferred and the other four would be conferred later this year.  Ms Christine Nixon, Chief Commissioner of Victoria Police, had been awarded an honorary degree in a previous year but had chosen to accept it this year and it had recently been conferred.

                       

Academic Board noted, without discussion, the approval of the Honorary Degrees Committee for the award of honorary degrees as presented orally by Professor Larkins, Vice-Chancellor.

 

    *6.2      Items 23 to 30 – Proposals to establish and fill the position of Professor                   

 

This item originated at items 23 to 30 of the agenda and was starred at the commencement of the meeting by the Vice-Chancellor.

 

Professor R Larkins, Vice-Chancellor, reminded the Board that Council had delegated to the Vice-Chancellor the power to approve all professorial positions.  As each position becomes vacant or a new position was to be established, filling the positions need to be carefully considered as the university was facing a tight financial position and “bracket creep” must be avoided.  All proposals for positions would require a justification for the position, a budget justification as well as an analysis in relation to the seniority of the position.  Consideration should be given to replacing at the lower levels as promotions occur, and establishing whether there is a need to fill the vacant position.  No quotas will be placed on the number of professorial staff as it would negate promotion on the basis of merit.  New positions must be endorsed by Academic Board to ensure that there is no overlap with other faculties.  All proposed new and existing professorial appointments will be carefully considered by the Vice-Chancellor’s Group.

 

In response to a statement that this would be a form of internal regulation and faculties with insufficient funds would fill positions at lower levels, the Vice-Chancellor advised that this has not been the trend at Monash.

 

Academic Board noted the advice of Professor Larkins, Vice-Chancellor.

 

 

C         ITEMS FOR APPROVAL OR INFORMATION

 

 

7          MATTERS REFERRED TO ACADEMIC BOARD BY COUNCIL

 

8          REPORTS OF THE ADMISSIONS COMMITTEE                                                                        

 

8.1       Receipt of Report of Admission Committee meeting 1/2005                RMO1998/1366                   

           

            A report was attached. (p 31-36)

 

Academic Board received and noted the Report of meeting 1/2005 of the Admissions Committee, held on 3 March 2005.

 

8.1.1   Amendment to Monash entry in the VTAC Guide                        RMO1997/0254      

 

The Admissions Committee reviewed a request from a secondary college concerning the possible penalisation of students who may take VCE units 3 and 4 in Year 10.  The discussion of Monash’s middle band statement in the VTAC Guide, which includes the possibility of a penalty for VCE students who take longer than three years to complete (or just three years to complete in Medicine), confirmed that this statement was redundant.  The Admissions Committee agreed that the statement should be deleted.                                   

 

Academic Board approved the deletion of the following section of the current VCE middle band statement in the VTAC Guide:

 

“If studies are completed within a three year period students will not be penalized.  Where studies take more than three years, this will be taken into account in re-ranking in the middle band. (Note: Medicine is an exception as students who take more than the minimum period are likely to be re-ranked downwards)”.

 

            Proceedings

 

 

9          REPORT OF THE EDUCATION COMMITTEE                                                                            

 

9.1       Receipt of Report of Education Committee meeting 2/2005                 RMO2004/0611       

           

            A report was attached. (p 37-40)

 

Academic Board received and noted the Report of meeting 2/2005 of the Education Committee, held on 16 March 2005.

 

            Proceedings

           

10        REPORT OF THE GENERAL LIBRARY COMMITTEE                                              RMO1997/0902

 

10.1     Receipt of Report of Meeting 1/2005                                                                         

           

A report was attached. (p 41-44) 

 

Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 1/2005 of the General Library Committee, held on 22 March 2005.

 

            Proceedings

 

 

11        REPORT OF THE HONORARY DEGREES COMMITTEE                                         RMO1997/1110                                                                                                                                                                                   

 

            11.1     Receipt of Report                                                                                                                            

 

A report was attached. (p 45-46)

 

Academic Board received and noted the Report of meeting 2/2004 of the Honorary Degrees Committee held on 10 December 2004.

 

    *11.2    Nominations for the Award of Honorary Degrees                                    RMO2003/085      

 

This item was dealt with at item 6.1 of the agenda.  The Vice-Chancellor spoke to this item.

 

Academic Board noted, without discussion, the approval of the Honorary Degrees Committee for the award of honorary degrees as presented orally by Professor Larkins, Vice-Chancellor.

 

 

12        REPORT OF THE RESEARCH GRADUATE SCHOOL COMMITTEE                                          

 

12.1     Receipt of Report of Meeting 2/2005                                                       RMO1997/1156       

           

A report was attached. (p 47-50). 

 

Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 2/2005 of the Research Graduate School Committee, held on 4 March 2005.

 

            Proceedings

 

12.2     Receipt of Report of Meeting 3/2005                                                       RMO1997/1156

           

A report was attached.  (p 51-76).

 

Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 3/2005 of the Research Graduate School Committee, held on 1 April 2005.

 

12.2.1  Joint International Doctorate (PhD) with the University of Naples Frederico II                                                                                                          RMO2005/0411

 

At meeting 6/2002 Academic Board approved the establishment of Cotutelle Doctoral programs.  The proposal submitted under item 1 of the report seeks to establish a Joint International Doctorate (PhD) between the University of Naples Frederico II and Monash University Faculty of Science is essentially the same as that approved  by Academic Board 6/2002 except that:

·         a student will take out a single qualification or degree jointly awarded by the two universities; and

·         an oral defence (viva voce) may or may not  form part of the examination process.

 

Academic Board approved the establishment of a Joint International Doctorate (PhD) between the University of Naples Frederico II and Monash University as detailed in Appendix 2 of Report 3/2005 of the Research Graduate School Committee.

 

12.2.2  Joint Masters program with a Chinese partner institution      RMO2005/0412

 

The proposal submitted under item 1 of the report 3/2005 was to establish a Joint Masters Program between a Chinese partner institution and the Monash University Faculty of Engineering.  The program under this proposal differed from the guidelines set down by the Research Graduate School Committee as follows:

·         while it is anticipated that a reciprocal arrangement will operate in a year or two, the present agreement is for Chinese students to undertake most of the research component of the degree at Monash University; and

·         candidates who complete the first year of coursework and preliminary research at the partner institution will then enrol at Monash University where they will complete the 12-18 month research component of the program.

 

Academic Board approved the establishment of a Joint Masters Program between a Chinese partner institution and the Monash University Faculty of Engineering, as detailed in Appendix 3 of Report 3/2005 of the Research Graduate School Committee.

 

            Proceedings

 

 

13        REPORT OF THE BOARD OF THE FACULTY OF BUSINESS AND ECONOMICS                    

 

13.1     Receipt of Report of Meetings 4/2004, 5/2004, 6/2004, 1/2005 and 2/2005            

                                                                                                                                  RMO1998/0456

            A report was attached. (p 77-88).

 

Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meetings 4/2004, 5/2004, 6/2004, 1/2005 and 2/2005 of the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics, held on 4 August 2004, 6 October 2004, 8 December 2004, 16 February 2005 and 20 April 2005.

 

13.1.1   Changes to faculty structure                                                       RMO2001/1346

 

            Under item 5 of the report, the Faculty Board had approved the following:

·         Monash University Centre for Pharmacy Management;

·         Centre for Regulatory Studies; and

·         Consumer and Retail Research Unit.

 

Academic Board noted that detailed proposals for the above will be submitted by the Faculty of Business and Economics to the Academic Board after endorsement by the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Research).

 

 

 

13.1.2   Establishment of the Taxation Law and Policy Research Institute              

 

A proposal was attached.  (265-268).

 

Academic Board endorsed, for transmission to Council for approval, the proposal by the Board of Faculty of Business and Economics to establish the Taxation Law and Policy Research Institute.

 

            Proceedings

 

 

14        REPORT OF THE BOARD OF THE FACULTY OF ENGINEERING                                            

 

14.1     Receipt of Report of Meeting 1/2005                                                       RMO1998/1368      

 

            A report was attached. (p 89-92).

 

Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 1/2005 of the Board of the Faculty of Engineering, held on 13 April 2005.

 

            Proceedings

 

 

15        REPORT OF THE BOARD OF THE FACULTY OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY                  

 

15.1     Receipt of Report of Meetings 1/2005, 2/2005 and Special meeting SCFB1/05

                                                                                                                                  RMO1997/1159

            A report was attached. (p 93-100).

 

Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meetings 1/2005, 2/2005 and special meeting SFCB 1/05 of the Board of the Faculty of Information Technology, held on 9 March 2005, 20 April 2005 and 7 April 2005 respectively.

 

Academic Board approved, for transmission to Council for noting, the proposal of the Board of the Faculty of Information Technology to disestablish the FLITE Centre (item 7 of report).

 

Academic Board endorsed, for transmission to Council for approval, the proposal of the Board of the Faculty of Information Technology, to disestablish the current school structure at Australian campuses.

 

Academic Board endorsed, for transmission to Council for approval, the proposal of the Board of the Faculty of Information Technology to establish a new campus-based school structure, as follows, in line with the recommendation of the strategic review, to take effect from the date of Council approval:

·         Berwick School of Information Technology

·         Caulfield School of Information Technology

·         Clayton School of Information Technology

·         Gippsland School of Information Technology

·         Peninsula School of Information Technology

 

            Proceedings

 

 

 

 

 

 

16        REPORT OF THE BOARD OF THE FACULTY OF LAW

 

            16.1     Receipt of Report of Meeting 1/2005                                                       RMO1998/1743

 

                        A report was attached. (p 101-104).

 

Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 1/2005 of the Board of the Faculty of Law, held on 7 April 2005.

 

Academic Board approved, for transmission to Council for noting, the proposal of the Board of the Faculty of Law, to disestablish the Centre for Law in the Digital Economy.

 

Academic Board approved, for transmission to Council for noting, the proposal of the Board of the Faculty of Law, to disestablish the Centre for the Study of Privatisation and Public Accountability.

 

           

17        REPORT OF THE BOARD OF THE FACULTY OF MEDICINE, NURSING AND HEALTH SCIENCES           

 

            17.1     Receipt of the Report of Meeting 2/2005                                                RMO1998/0708

 

                        A report was attached. (p 105-116)

 

            Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 2/2005 of the Board of the Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences, held on 27 April 2005.

 

17.1.1    Revised Faculty Management Structure                                     RMO1998/0296      

 

The Faculty Executive and Faculty Board had proposed that a new management structure be put in place, comprising the Dean and General Manager, plus the redesignation of some Associate Dean positions into Deputy Dean positions as follows and as detailed in Appendix A of the faculty report:

 

Senior Deputy Dean – international affairs and student affairs;

Deputy Dean (Teaching) – undergraduate and postgraduate coursework teaching, and quality management;

Deputy Dean (Research) – research activities and postgraduate research degrees;

Deputy Dean (Strategic Development) – strategic developments in the medical precinct, eg new biomedical institute in the STRIP 2/3 buildings, development of the new Mental Health Research Institute; and

Associate Deans (MBBS Curriculum), (Postgraduate Coursework Degrees), (Postgraduate Research Degrees) and (Biotechnology Development) as at present.

 

Academic Board endorsed, for transmission to Council for noting, the revised management structure of the Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences as proposed.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

18        REPORTS OF THE BOARD OF THE FACULTY OF SCIENCE                                                   

 

18.1     Receipt of Report of Meeting 1/2005                                                       RMO1997/0904

 

            A report was attached. (p 117-120)

 

Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 1/2005 of the Board of the Faculty of Science, held on 2 March 2005.

 

Academic Board approved, for transmission to Council for noting, the proposal of the Board of the Faculty of Science to disestablish the Centre for X-Ray Physics and Imaging.

 

            Proceedings

 

18.2     Receipt of Report of Meeting 2/2005                                                       RMO1997/0904

 

            A report was attached. (p 121-124).

 

Academic Board received and noted the Report of Meeting 2/2005 of the Board of the Faculty of Science, held on 20 April 2005.

 

            Proceedings

 

 

19        LEGISLATION

 

19.1     Amendment pursuant to Statute 2.3 Faculties Regulations (Amendment 2 2005)       RMO1997/1504                                                                                                                                        

 

Documents were attached. (p 125-128).  These regulations amend Schedule 6 of the Faculties Regulations to reflect the restructure of the Faculty of Information Technology’s Australian campuses into five campus-based schools.

 

Academic Board endorsed, for submission to Council, the proposal to amend Faculties Regulations (Amendment No 2 2005).

 

 

20        PROPOSAL TO ESTABLISH AND FILL THE POSITION OF DIRECTOR OF

            E-RESEARCH                                                                                                                             

 

A proposal by the Office of the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Research) was attached. (p 145-154).

                                                                                                                                                                

Academic Board endorsed for transmission to the Vice-Chancellor, the proposal, submitted by the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Research), to establish and fill the position of Professor and Director of E-Research, e-Research @ Monash Centre.

 

 

21        ACADEMIC BOARD MEMBERSHIP

 

            21.1     Casual vacancies on Academic Board as at meeting 3/2005                RMO2004/1174

           

                        The following casual vacancies existed on Academic Board as at meeting 3/2005:

 

                        Faculty                                   Vacancy                                       Expiry Date

                        Engineering                            Non-Professorial Member              30/6/2005                   

 

            21.2     Nomination from Faculty Board to fill a casual vacancy on Academic Board

                                                                                                                                  RMO2004/1174

 

Academic Board noted the following appointment made by the Faculty board to fill a casual professorial vacancy on Academic Board:

 

                        Professor Catriona McLean            Medicine                      until 30 June 2006.

 

 

22        REPORT OF COUNCIL

 

22.1     Receipt of Report of Meeting 2/2005                                                       RMO1998/1225      

 

            A report was attached. (p 155-158).

 

Academic Board noted the items of interest from Council Meeting 2/2005 held on 21 March 2005.

 

            Proceedings

 

*23      PROPOSAL TO ESTABLISH AND FILL THE POSITION OF PROFESSOR OF FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING AND AUDITING                                                                                                                 RMO2001/1346      

 

A proposal by the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics was attached. (p 165-182).

 

Academic Board endorsed, for transmission to the Vice-Chancellor for approval, the proposal submitted by the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic), of the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics to establish and fill the position of Professor of Financial Accounting and Auditing, Department of Accounting and Finance.

 

 

*24      PROPOSAL TO ESTABLISH AND FILL THE POSITION OF PROFESSOR OF FINANCE RMO2001/1346

 

A proposal by the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics was attached. (p 183-190).

 

Academic Board endorsed, for transmission to the Vice-Chancellor for approval, the proposal submitted by the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic), of the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics to establish and fill the position of Professor of Finance, Department of Accounting and Finance.

 

 

*25      PROPOSAL TO ESTABLISH AND FILL THE POSITION OF PROFESSOR IN THE SCHOOL OF BUSINESS, MONASH UNIVERSITY MALAYSIA                                                                          RMO2001/1346      

 

A proposal by the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics was attached. (p 191-200).

 

Academic Board endorsed, for transmission to the Vice-Chancellor for approval, the proposal submitted by the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic), of the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics to establish and fill the position of Professor in the School of Business, Monash University Malaysia.

 

 

 

*26      PROPOSAL TO ESTABLISH AND FILL THE POSITION OF PROFESSOR IN THE CENTRE FOR HEALTH ECONOMICS                                                                                                            RMO2001/1346      

 

A proposal by the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics was attached. (p 201-212),

 

Academic Board endorsed, for transmission to the Vice-Chancellor for approval, the proposal submitted by the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic), of the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics to establish and fill the position of Professor in the Centre for Health Economics.

 

 

*27      PROPOSAL TO ESTABLISH AND FILL THE POSITION OF PROFESSOR OF ECONOMICS RMO2001/1346    

 

A proposal by the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics was attached. (p 213-222).

 

Academic Board endorsed, for transmission to the Vice-Chancellor for approval, the proposal submitted by the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic), of the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics to establish and fill the position of Professor of Economics, Department of Economics.

 

 

*28      PROPOSAL TO ESTABLISH AND FILL THE POSITION OF PROFESSOR AND HEAD, DEPARTMENT OF ECONOMICS                                                                                                            RMO2001/1346      

 

A proposal by the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics was attached. (p 223-236).

 

Academic Board endorsed, for transmission to the Vice-Chancellor for approval, the proposal submitted by the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic), of the Board of the Faculty of Business and Economics to establish and fill the position of Professor and Head, Department of Economics.

 

 

 *29     PROPOSAL TO ESTABLISH AND FILL THE POSITION OF PROFESSOR AND DIRECTOR OF OBSTETRICS IN THE DEPARTMENT OF OBSTETRICS AND GYNAECOLOGY, SOUTHERN CLINICAL SCHOOL IN CONJUNCTION WITH SOUTHERN HEALTH                                                            RMO1999/2105      

 

A proposal by the Board of the Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences was attached. (p 237-252).

 

Academic Board endorsed, for transmission to the Vice-Chancellor for approval, the proposal submitted by the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic), of the Board of the Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences to establish and fill the position of Professor and Director of Obstetrics, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Southern Clinical School in conjunction with Southern Health.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

*30      PROPOSAL TO ESTABLISH AND FILL THE POSITION OF PROFESSOR AND DIRECTOR OF AGED CARE, BAYSIDE HEALTH AGED CARE PROGRAMME, DEPARTMENT OF MEDICINE, CENTRAL & EASTERN CLINICAL SCHOOL IN CONJUNCTION WITH BAYSIDE HEALTH                           RMO2002/0435      

 

A proposal by the Board of the Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences, was attached. (p 253-264).

 

Academic Board endorsed, for transmission to the Vice-Chancellor for approval, the proposal submitted by the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic), of the Board of the Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences to establish and fill the position of Professor and Director of Aged Care, Bayside Health Aged Care Programme, Department of Medicine, Central and Eastern Clinical School in conjunction with Bayside Health.

 

31        NEXT MEETING

 

            The next meeting of the Academic Board will be held on Wednesday, 6 July 2005 from 2:15 pm – 4:30 pm in Lecture Theatre G121, Ground Floor, Building 903, Berwick Campus.