Skip to content | Change text size
Assets | Includes | header.shtml
 

Education Committee - Meeting 4-2008

Meeting No. 4/2008 of the Education Committee was held on 30 July 2008 in the Sir George Lush Room, Building 3a, Clayton campus.

MINUTES

Part A    Procedural Matters

*1 Attendance and Apologies

There were present:
Professor Adam Shoemaker (Chair), Dr Lorraine Bennett, Professor Barbara Caine (for Professor Jayne Godfrey), Dr Angela Carbone, Mr Joe Choy, Associate Professors Gary Codner and Craig de Wilde, Dr Melissa De Zwart, Professors Merran Evans and Owen Hughes, Ms Catherine Harboe-Ree, Ms Dash Jayasuriya, Ms Glenda Key, Professors Max King and Tony Luff, Mr Terry Masocco, Associate Professor Sid Nair, Professor Tony Patti, Dr Geoff Romeo, Ms Kate Roth (via teleconference), Professor Peter Schelluch (via teleconference), Professor Peter Stewart, Associate Professor David Taylor, Ms Joanne Tyler, Dr Cristina Varsavsky, Professor Walter Wong (via teleconference).

Membership change:
Members were advised that Ms Tara Trickey had resigned as the Education, Community and Welfare Officer (ECWO) at MONSU Peninsula. The Chair expressed his thanks for the contribution that Ms Trickey had made to Education Committee. The Chair informed members that Ms Claire Heath had been appointed as the new MONSU Peninsula member of Education Committee.

Apologies were received from:
Professor Jayne Godfrey (represented by Professor Barbara Caine), Associate Professors Louise McCall and Robert Nelson.

In attendance:
Mr Michael Fenaughty (Secretary). Ms Sue Bell. Ms Leanne McCann, Learning Skills Manager, and Ms Lisa Smith, Director, Client Services – Humanities and Social Sciences, Monash University Library (for item 11.1). Ms Moh-Lee Ng, Executive Manager, Risk and Legal Compliance, Audit and Risk Management (as a participant in the Women’s Leadership Program and at the invitation of Professor M Evans), Mr Peter Yates.

The Chair welcomed:

  • Professors Schelluch and Wong, and Ms Roth attending via teleconference;
  • Associate Professor Craig de Wilde (Faculty of Arts member);
  • Ms Claire Heath (MONSU Peninsula representative) who was attending her first meeting of Education Committee; and
  • Ms Moh-Lee Ng.

*2 Arrangement of Agenda and Starring of Items

All unstarred items on the agenda were adopted without discussion and the actions recommended taken or the information therein noted. Item 10.2 was starred and the Chair confirmed that all components of item 11 were starred.

*3 Minutes

The minutes of meeting 3/2008 held on Wednesday 11 June were confirmed.

The minutes are located at: http://www.adm.monash.edu.au/execserv

*4 Chair’s Report

Professor Shoemaker informed members of the very extensive and successful program of activities to celebrate the tenth anniversary of Sunway campus, Malaysia held during the week of Monday 21 July. Of particular note was:

  • the two day Research Forum that included the launch of the Monash University Accident Research Centre, Malaysia, with strong support for this initiative being provided by Professor Dato’ Radin Umar, Director General, Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Higher Education, Malaysia;
  • the attendance of key personnel from several Malaysian research-intensive universities;
  • an extensive program of seminars that addressed a range of issues in relation to learning, teaching and research;
  • showcases for e-Education and the Monash Passport Program; and
  • the initiation of discussions between senior Monash staff and Professor Dato’ Radin Umar for the introduction of split PhD programs, whereby candidates will be able to undertake international field work within such programs. It is proposed that the programs would enable candidates to undertake a Monash PhD whilst also undertaking study at research-intensive Malaysian universities, among others.

4.1 Update on Monash Passport Program

The Chair informed members that the components of the Monash Passport Program will encourage student mobility between campuses, in particular amongst postgraduate students, with an emphasis on research and research training linkages across international borders.

The terms of the Memorandum of Understanding between Monash and Oxfam had been agreed and the first Oxfam nine internships will commence in February 2009. Participants will include three Monash South Africa students. It is also anticipated that in the near future further agreements with non-government organisations will be negotiated.

4.2 Monash Honours Project

Professor Shoemaker informed members that work on the Monash Honours Project, to reform Honours at the University, was progressing. Two successful half-day seminars had been conducted in June, with valuable feedback received from several focus groups.

Professor King suggested that, as there was such a high level of interest in Honours reforms in the University, it would be an opportune time to create an Honours Project Sub-Committee of Education Committee to develop strategies, policies and to propose concrete actions and reforms as a priority. There was strong interest in this idea amongst members.

Members were advised that Mr Adrian Devey could provide executive support to the Sub-Committee. The Chair invited Education Committee members who wished to participate in the Sub-Committee to contact Professors Shoemaker or King. During discussion, the following points were made:

  • the terms of reference and scope of the Project would be important when members were considering who should be nominated to the sub-committee;
  • strategic and policy decisions within the scope of the Project sub-committee should be also considered by Education Committee;
  • the Education Policy and Planning Committee would be involved in the Project on an ongoing basis;
  • as many colleagues had indicated that work on the Project should proceed as soon as possible, the Project could be fast tracked;
  • participation by representatives of student organisations was encouraged;
  • issues in relation to minimum standards for assessment and course length, along with the configuration of internal and external examiners, would be considered; and
  • the adequacy of current procedures to notify students that they had been granted scholarships by Monash should also be considered.

Resolution:

It was agreed that the terms of reference for the Monash Honours Project Sub-committee and an invitation to join the sub-committee would be circulated to Education Committee members within 48 hours of the conclusion of this Education Committee meeting.

For more information on the Monash Honours Project go to: http://www.odvce.monash.edu.au/projects/honours/project-plan-04-08.rtf

For Action/Information: Professors A Shoemaker and M King

Part B    Policy and Committee Matters

5 Matters Arising from the Minutes

Monash Honours Project and further data on Honours trends (minute 5.1 refers).

Executive Services Note: Members were advised that it is anticipated that further data on Honours trends will be presented by a representative of the Monash Honours Project Sub-committee to the September meeting of Education Committee.

6 Academic Board Matters – Meeting 4-2008

Items referred to Academic Board 4-08.

As Academic Board meeting 4-08 was cancelled, items referred by Education Committee to Academic Board will proceed to meeting 5-08 scheduled for 3 September.

7 Learning, Teaching and Quality Committee

No meeting held.

8 Education Policy and Programs Committee

Receipt of Report

Education Committee received and noted the report of the Education Policy and Programs Committee meeting 4-2008 held on 24 June.

9 Education Technology Committee

Receipt of Report

Education Committee received and noted the report of the Education Technology Committee meeting 5-2008 held on 12 June.

10 Coursework Admissions and Scholarships Committee (CASC)

10.1 Receipt of Report

Education Committee received and noted the Report of Meeting 2/2008 of the Coursework Admissions and Scholarships Committee held on 8 May.

10.2 Early Offers Pathway into Diploma of Tertiary (formerly Foundation) Studies

CASC meeting 2-2008 endorsed a proposal that the early offer pathway into the Diploma of Tertiary (formerly Foundation) Studies be extended for another year (2009) beyond the three year pilot period originally approved by Academic Board, for transmission to Education Committee for endorsement, then to Academic Board for approval.

Members were informed that the measures detailed by the proposal would ensure that admission criteria had been strengthened. It was noted that early offers were conditional on applicants meeting the University’s English language entry requirements, achieving the Diploma of Tertiary Studies ENTER score requirement of 50, and satisfying any specific VCE study score prerequisites for their intended bachelor’s degree.

Resolution:

Education Committee endorsed the proposal that the early offer pathway into the Diploma of Tertiary (formerly Foundation) Studies be extended for another year (2009), for transmission to Academic Board, with the proviso that the early offers are to be conditional on applicants:

  1. meeting the University’s English language entry requirements;
  2. achieving the Diploma of Tertiary Studies ENTER score requirement of 50; and
  3. satisfying any specific VCE study score prerequisites for their intended bachelor’s degree.

For Action/Information: Mr M Fenaughty, Mr M Hatwell

Part C    Other Items

*11 Other Business

11.1 Update on the Monash University Library Learning Skills Activities and Programs

The Chair invited Ms Smith to update Education Committee on Learning Skills Activities and Programs offered by the Library.

Ms Smith informed members that the meeting was an opportune time to provide members with an update on learning skills activities and programs offered by the Library over the past 12 months since the introduction of Learning Skills Advisors. The broad context of student learning at Monash relates to the core skills and attributes with which the University wishes to equip its graduates. These are led by a holistic approach to developing such skills and providing a service available to all students. Of particular note was:

The Library has conducted a total of 473 learning skills sessions with a grand total of 8011 participants;

  • When planning the renovation of Library spaces, there was an emphasis on creating further student-centred spaces that would encourage collaboration;
  • Introduction of flexible furniture and spaces for staff and student use;
  • A Learning Skills Advisor will be recruited at Monash South Africa;
  • A review of learning support at Sunway campus, Malaysia is being undertaken.

Ms Smith introduced Ms McCann, who briefed members on the processes that staff teaching units in the Faculty of Business and Economics Foundation Year, supported by Learning Skills Advisors and Librarians, had undertaken to redevelop a curriculum of six core first year units, including assessment tasks and skills development. The Learning Skills Advisors are also undertaking work with academic staff from the faculties of Law, Information Technology, Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences, and Pharmacy, with further strategies to be developed in collaboration with staff at Berwick campus.

In response to a question from a member, the challenges associated with working with students close to completing their degrees who were presenting with poor written English skills were acknowledged. Ms McCann emphasised the importance for students to attend learning skills sessions as close as possible to the commencement of their studies. It was noted that statistics comparing the user level of learning skills programs offered by the Library and the previous provider, the Centre for Learning and Teaching, would be difficult to obtain; however, a number of members expressed a high level of satisfaction with current service provision by the Library.

Resolution:

It was agreed that Professor Shoemaker and Ms Harboe-Ree would meet to discuss the preparation of a report on learning skills activities and programs offered by the Library for consideration by Academic Board and Council.

For Action/Information: Professor A Shoemaker Ms C Harboe-Ree

Executive Services Note: A copy of the PowerPoint presentation accompanies these minutes.

11.2 Increase of the Maximum Number of International Students Registered on the Commonwealth Register of Institutions and Courses for Overseas Students

Ms Roth provided a briefing to members on a proposal to increase the maximum number of international students registered on the Commonwealth Register of Institutions and Courses for Overseas Students (CRICOS) from the current maximum of 10,000 to 12,000 students.

It was noted that the application to increase the maximum number of international students would have as much information about the University’s operations as possible and, further, it was anticipated that this would negate the need for an inspection of the University’s operations after the application had been lodged to the relevant government authority.

The Chair advised members that the Office of the Deputy Vice-Chancellor (International) would consult with faculties in terms of available facilities and capacity issues and assured members that the increase of the maximum to 12,000 students was not explicitly linked to the abolition of full-fee places for domestic students.

Resolution:

Education Committee:

  1. noted the intention to request an increase to 12,000 in the maximum number of international students at Monash University registered on CRICOS; and
  2. endorsed the ongoing process as detailed for periodically reviewing the maximum number of international students at Monash and registered on CRICOS.

For Action/Information: Ms Roth

11.3 Listing of Monash Courses on the AusLIST Website

Ms Roth informed members that the AusLIST website is a new initiative developed by the Federal Government to provide international students with access to information regarding registered tertiary courses available in Australia.

Members informed Ms Roth that there were a number of courses listed in Appendix Two to the document that appeared to be duplicates with several course codes e.g. there were three different course codes for the Doctor of Philosophy offered at Sunway campus, Malaysia. A member advised that this was the result of classifications of new course codes for low cost disciplines.

Resolution:

Education Committee:

  1. noted the intention to list all relevant courses on the AusLIST website; and
  2. requested that Ms Roth correct the listing of courses detailed by Appendix Two before listing of all relevant courses on the AusLIST website.

For Action/Information: Ms Roth

Part D    Faculty Reports

No reports.

Part E    Other Business and Next Meeting

12 Other Business

12.1 Lectures Online

A member informed the meeting that there was strong student support for all lectures to be available to students online, with a preference for the current ‘opt in’ system to be amended to an ‘opt out’ structure. During discussion, the following points were made:

  • availability of lectures would be on the basis of providing an Authcate password;
  • the most significant uptake of lectures currently available online via the Library website was prior to the exam period, indicating that such lectures were utilised by students for revision purposes;
  • there are a number of lecture theatres that do not have the technical capacity for audio recording of lectures;
  • there are significant copyright issues preventing online availability of lectures by School of Music staff (and other disciplines);
  • the review of the Lectopia trial would be an appropriate forum for consideration of the request to make recordings of all lectures available online; and
  • such a proposal would have resource and budget implications.

Resolution:

It was agreed that the recording of all lectures and subsequently making the recordings available online would be an item for consideration by the next Education Committee meeting.

For Action/Information: Mr M Fenaughty

13 Next Meeting

Meeting 5/2008 will be held on Wednesday 3 September at 12.00 noon in the Sir George Lush Room, Building 3a, Clayton Campus. The Chair invited members to note that, in order to accommodate members also attending the Academic Board meeting commencing at 3.30pm on 3 September, Education Committee will commence at 12.00 noon. A light lunch will be provided. Final submissions for the agenda for this meeting are due by Wednesday, 20 August 2008.