Skip to content | Change text size
Assets | Includes | header.shtml
 

Council Meeting 3-2009

Meeting 3/2009 of the Monash University Council was held on Monday, 25 May 2009 in the Advancement Meeting Room, Level 9, Building H, at Caulfield Campus.

MINUTES

1      Procedural Matters

1.1    Apologies                                                                                                            

Dr Leanne Rowe, Mr Ian Nethercote and Mr Yehudi Blacher were apologies.
Professor Stephanie Fahey, Deputy Vice-Chancellor (International) was unable to attend the meeting.

1.2    Special Leave

Ms Lesley Boston had been granted special leave for this meeting.
Mr Shane Buggle has been granted special leave for meeting 5/2009 (17 August).
Ms Louise Adler requested and was granted special leave for meeting 6/2009 (12 October).

1.3    Starring of Items

Items 1.1 Apologies; 1.2 Special Leave; 1.3 Starring of Items; 1.4 Approval of Non-Starred Items; 2.1 Transition Report on the commencement of Professor Ed. Byrne, 2.2 Report of the Selection and Remuneration Committee; 2.3 Special Professorial Appointments Committee (SPAC) - Translation from a Committee of Council to a Committee operating under delegation from Council to the Vice-Chancellor (Management Committee), 3.1 Minutes of Meeting No. 2/2009, 4.1 Monash/WorkSafe/TAC Research Institute, 5.0 Report to Council by the Pro Vice-Chancellor Gippsland, 6.1 Chancellor's Report, 6.2 Proposal to establish a "Campus Master Planning Committee, 6.3 proposal to establish International Council Associates, 7.1 Vice-Chancellor's Report to Council, 7.2 Update on University 2009 Financials (April), 7.3 Report on Implications of the Victorian and Federal Budgets, 7.4 Monash University Ethics Statement, 8.1 Receipt of the Report of Resources and Finance Committee, 9.0 Report of the Academic Board, 10.0 Report of the Gippsland Advisory Council (Meeting 2/2009), 11.0 Report of the Equal Opportunity Committee,  12.1 Advancement Portfolio Report and 12.3 Use of the University Seal were starred for discussion.

1.4    Approval of Non-Starred Items

Council resolved on the motion of the Chancellor that all items on the agenda not starred be adopted without discussion, and the action recommended be taken or the information therein noted.    

2      Business in Camera

2.1    Transition Report on the commencement of Professor Ed. Byrne

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/45

2.2    Report of the Selection and Remuneration Committee

During discussion the following amendments were approved:

  • Pro Vice-Chancellor Selection Panel - to include the President of the Academic Board or nominee;
  • Pro Vice-Chancellor Selection Panel - to include a student from an appropriate constituency when the position relates to ‘the student experience'; and
  • Vice-President Selection Panel - to include a member of the professional staff.

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/46

Council:

  • Noted the report of Meeting 1/2009 of the Selection and Remuneration Committee; and
  • approved the table at Attachment A as the framework of policy, process and practice for the recruitment and appointment of senior staff of the university subject to the amendments detailed above.

Council noted that nothing in the framework precluded the Council from making direct appointments of senior staff (either external or from within the university), in exceptional circumstances, such as attracting or retaining outstanding staff member(s).

2.3    Special Professorial Appointments Committee (SPAC) - Translation from a Committee of Council to a Committee operating under delegation from Council to the Vice-Chancellor (Management Committee)

During discussion of paragraph 7 (page 9 of the agenda papers), Council noted advice that a potential conflict of interest may arise in circumstances where the Vice-Chancellor, Dean and President of the Academic Board were all from the same discipline.  Council resolved to amend paragraph 7 by addition of the following:

"in circumstances where the Vice-Chancellor, Dean and President of the Academic Board are all from the same discipline the President of Academic Board is to nominate a Deputy President of the Academic Board to consider the matter for endorsement."

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/47

Council approved:

  • that from 1 June 2009 SPAC ceases to operate as a Committee of Council;
  • that from 1 June 2009 the Vice-Chancellor should form a management committee in accordance with the approved framework at Attachment A to assume the work of SPAC;
  • that from 1 June 2009 the Vice-Chancellor is delegated authority by Council to make special professorial appointments as per the operating arrangements at Attachment B subject to the amendment detailed above.

3.      Confirmation of Minutes of Previous Meeting

3.1    Minutes of Meeting No. 2/2009

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/48

Council confirmed the Minutes of Meeting No. 2/2009 held on Monday 23 March 2009.

4      Matters Arising from the Minutes

4.1    Monash/WorkSafe/TAC Research Institute

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/49

Council noted the further detail relating to the governance arrangements of the Research Institute. 

5      Report to Council by the Pro Vice-Chancellor Gippsland

Professor Helen Bartlett, Pro Vice-Chancellor Gippsland Campus provided Council with a presentation on key aspects of the Gippsland Campus including:

  • the regional context and demographics of the campus;
  • the campus budget and relationship with faculties;
  • enrolment load including both on and off campus load, indigenous student numbers, international students and Open Universities enrolled students serviced by the campus;
  • achievements including the Gippsland Access and GAP Project programs, the establishment of a Chair in Geotechnical Engineering, success in the Learning and Teaching Performance Fund and increased Koori enrolments, good outcomes in unit evaluations, improved research capacity and outcomes and significant and ongoing involvement with the community exemplified by the role the campus played in the recent bushfire response; and
  • the key challenges for the campus including enhancing enrolment levels and finding new international student markets, diversifying funding sources, continuing the improvement in research activity, fine tuning the staffing profile of the campus and upgrading of campus infrastructure.

During discussion members noted the challenge of increasing enrolments and attracting international students from diversified markets, the importance of retaining and enhancing discipline linkages across campuses, initiatives to enhance research activity and the target of upgrading the campuses infrastructure.

Concluding the presentation, Professor Bartlett thanked the campus staff for the support and dedication to the campus, students and the community - particularly commending the staff's contribution to the recent bushfire effort.

The Chancellor, on behalf of Council, thanked Professor Bartlett for her insightful presentation and commended the staff and local community for their exemplary community spirit during the recent bushfire tragedy.

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/50

Council received the advice of Professor Helen Bartlett, Pro Vice-Chancellor Gippsland Campus.                                   

6      Chancellor's Business

6.1    Chancellor's Report to Council

Professor Richard Larkins, Vice-Chancellor, Monash University

The Chancellor sought the approval of Council to make a short statement, on behalf of Council, as this was the Professor Larkin's final meeting as a member the Council,

The Chancellor thanked Professor Larkins for his outstanding contribution to Monash noting that Professor Larkins was leaving the University well placed to meet the challenges ahead.

Under Professor Larkins guidance and leadership, Monash has evolved into a distinctive centre of innovative thinking and teaching and a research leader.  Research at Monash has flourished as evidenced by the establishment of the Australian Regenerative Medicine institute, the Centre for Electron Microscopy and the Monash Antibody Technologies Facility.  Innovative learning and teaching has advanced as evidenced by Monash Passport program, modernisation of lecture and tutorial rooms and the establishment of Ancora Imparo student leadership program.  Monash's international footprint has continued to grow under Professor Larkins with the completion of a new campus in Malaysia, continued and sustained growth in South Africa and the opening of a joint research training institute with the Indian Institute of Technology Bombay.

On a personal note, the Chancellor outlined some of the attributes that had made Professor Larkins a leader among Vice-Chancellors.  Richard's capacity to recall and debate fine detail, his commitment to Monash,, Richard's ability to recruit ‘stars' at both the management and academic level resulting in Monash being one of the best people resourced Universities in Australia and Richard's support of his staff and the University sector as a whole leaves behind a unique individual contribution.  Richard's contribution had positively impacted the lives of all who know him and, as importantly, many thousands of people who have never met Richard but have been the recipients of initiatives and outcomes guided by Richard Larkin's leadership at Monash.

Council supported the statement of the Chancellor, with acclamation, and wished Professor Larkins success with all his future endeavours.

Council visit to Gippsland Campus

A draft program was tabled at the meeting

Following discussion Council approved that meeting 7/2009 (16 November) be held at the Gippsland Campus.  Further, the draft program for the days activities was endorsed subject to investigation into the possibility of including an indigenous welcome during the lunch break and ensuring appropriate student involvement.

South Africa

Council noted the advice of the Chancellor that the dates had been confirmed and that further information on the proposed itinerary would be provided at meeting 4/2009.

Review of Equal Opportunity Committee

The Chancellor advised Council that he had discussed the matter with Professor Bourke, Chair - Equal Opportunity Committee, and the Deputy Chancellors and all had agreed that the proposed review should not proceed as the Committee was achieving appropriate outcomes and a costly external review would be unlikely to achieve any significant return.

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/51                                                                                     

Council:

  1. Council recorded, with acclamation, a minute of appreciation of the service, dedication and significant contribution made by Professor Richard Larkins, Vice-Chancellor of Monash University from 1 September 2003 to 5 July 2009;
  2. approved that Council meeting 7/2009 be held at the Gippsland Campus including a program of activities for those Councillors able to arrive at the campus earlier in the day;
  3. noted that a further report on the program for the Council visit to South Africa campus would be presented to the next meeting of Council; and
  4. endorsed the Councillor's recommendation that an external review of Equal Opportunity Committee should not proceed as previously discussed at the Council Conference.

6.2    Proposal to establish a "Campus Master Planning Committee"

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/52

Council approved:

  1. the establishment of a working party to develop terms of reference for a proposed committee to oversee the built environment planning; and
  2. that the working party consist of the Chancellor, the Vice-Chancellor, one Council member with appropriate experience (Mr Yehudi Blacher), the Vice-President (Administration), the Vice-President (Finance),  and the Dean of the Faculty of Art & Design.                               

6.3    Proposal to establish International Council Associates

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/53

Council approved the establishment of a Working Group consisting of Dr Alan Finkel, Mr Paul Ramler, Dr. Charles Curwen, Professor Colin Bourke, Professor Jayne Godfrey and Professor Stephanie Fahey to further develop option 2 as detailed in the agenda papers. 

7      Vice-Chancellor's Business

7.1    Vice-Chancellor's Report to Council

The Vice-Chancellor elaborated on his distributed report as follows:

Commonwealth Budget

Highlights included a commitment by the government to improved indexation of funding for both teaching and research block infrastructure funding commencing in 2012 with interim measures to be phased in the areas of ‘performance funding' and ‘equity funding'.  On the other hand, there will be very little increase to operational funding this year and next.

International Student Recruitment

Applications had plateaued with no evidence of a substantial increase in the acceptance of offers.

Other matters

The Vice-Chancellor had recently attended Board meetings in both South Africa and Malaysia.  A pleasing feature of the visit to South Africa was that the campus had met its projected enrolment numbers without further reliance on students from Botswana.

EIF - Submissions for the third round of funding are likely to be called for in July / August with outcome announced in December.

Concluding his report, The Vice-Chancellor thanked Council for its support and guidance during his term as Vice-Chancellor and recorded his appreciation for the enjoyable and productive interactions between himself and the Council and individual Councillors.

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/54                                                                                     

Council received the report of the Vice-Chancellor and recorded the Vice-Chancellor's note of appreciation to Council for Council's support and assistance during his tenure as Vice-Chancellor of Monash University.

7.2    Update on University 2009 Financials (May)

Mr David Pitt, Vice-President (Finance) provided Council with an update on the University's finances.  Key aspects of the presentation included:

  • an operating surplus of $107.3m including major contributions from the Teaching and Learning Capital Fund, a one-off contribution from Monash College and funding via an EIF Grant;
  • a forecast improvement in the cash position due to increased government grants and government funding for projects including the New Horizon building;
  • capital expenditure over budget largely due to the early commencement of some capital works;
  • strong overall student demand;
  • staff and related expenses remained close to budget noting that management had approved a 2% salary increase (from April) while EB negotiations continued:

During discussion, Council was advised that the capacity of lecture theatres was being carefully monitored as was the size of tutorials.

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/55

Council received the Financial Report for the period ending May 2009.

7.3    Report on implications of the 2009 Victorian and Federal Budgets

Mr Pitt provided Council with an update on the major financial outcomes of the Federal budget.  Copies of the slides are attached for information.

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/56

Council received the advice of the Mr. David Pitt, Vice-President (Finance).

7.4    Monash University Ethics Statement

During discussion, Council was advised that the Ethics Statement would be promulgated to existing staff and students and incorporated into the staff induction process and that on completion the Research Ethics Policy would be presented to Council for consideration.

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/57

Council approved the Monash University Ethics Statement.

8      Resources and Finance Committee

8.1    Receipt of Report of Resources and Finance Committee

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/58

Council received the Report of Meeting No. 2/2009 of the Resources and Finance Committee held on Thursday 30 April 2009.

8.2    Monash University Financial Reports:  March 2009

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/59

Council noted:

  • the University's position and performance as presented in the March 2009 paper; and
  • the Committee's comments on management's current course of action as a result of the review.

8.3    Annual Course Fee Review Process:  Proposed Changes

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/60

Council approved:

  • The proposal to streamline the course fee review process; and
  • The amendment of the Monash University Regulations as detailed in the attached documentation.

8.4    Proceedings of Resource and Finance Committee

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/61

Council noted the proceedings of meeting 2/2009 of the Resources and Finance Committee.

9      Academic Board

9.1    Receipt of Report of Academic Board

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/62

Council received and note the Report of Meeting No. 2/2009 of the Academic Board held on Wednesday 22 April 2009.

9.2    Monash University Ethics Statement

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/63

Council noted that Academic Board endorsed the Monash University Ethics Statement.

10      Report of the Gippsland Advisory Council Meeting 2/2009

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/64

Council received and noted the Report of Meeting No. 2/2009 of the Gippsland Advisory Council held on Tuesday 21 April 2009.

11      Report of the Equal Opportunity Committee

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/65

Council received the report of the Equal Opportunity Committee held on 27 April 2009.

12      General Business

12.1    Advancement Portfolio Report

Council noted advice that campaign activity was continuing however all charities were experiencing a slowdown due to the economic climate.  Recent initiatives include a staff philanthropic campaign run in April which achieved very pleasing results while an alumni email appeal campaign would take place in June.

A Councillor requested additional information on the recruitment of indigenous students and Council was informed that further information would be provide at the next meeting of Council.

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/66

Council received the report titled Advancement Portfolio Report for University Council May 2009.

12.2     Senior Appointments

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/67

Council noted:

  • that the persons named in the documents had accepted the indicated offers of appointment approved by Vice-Chancellor;
  • that the persons named in the document had accepted the indicated offers of appointment approved by the Special Professorial Appointments Committee of Council.

12.3     Use of University Seal

In response to a query relating to the affixing of the University Seal to lease documents, Council was advised that future reports would be revised to enhance transparency of matters reported to Council.

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/68

Council noted the report of the Vice-Chancellor dated 14 May 2009 on the affixing of the Common Seal to documents executed under Seal pursuant to Statute 8.1, Section 2.1.5.

12.4     University Entrance and Admission to Courses Regulations (Amendment No. 1 2009)

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/69

Council made the University Entrance and Admission to Courses Regulations (Amendment No. 1 2009).

12.5   Monash University Prato - Change of Legal Representative

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/70

Council:

  • Revoked the authority of Dr. Pagliaro as Monash University legal representative in Italy. Such revocation is contained in the attached Appointment and Power of Attorney instrument; and
  • Appointed Professor Loretta Baldassar as Monash University's legal representative in Italy, with powers as described in the attached Appointment and Power of Attorney instrument, and that the said instrument be executed under the Common Seal of Monash University.

13        Report of the Executive Committee of Council

The Executive Committee of Council, acting under its delegation from Council approved by circulation on the 8th May 2009 the proposal to appoint Associate Professor Marnie Hughes-Warrington as Professor and Pro Vice-Chancellor (Learning and Teaching ).

RESOLUTION CL3/2009/71

Council noted the approval granted by the Executive Committee of Council on 8th May 2009.

14        Next meeting

The next meeting of Council is scheduled to be held on Monday, 6 July 2009 in the Advancement Meeting Room, Level 9, Building H, Caulfield Campus.

Further Information

Inquiries about any of the business listed above, or on Council matters in general, may be directed to Mr Tony Calder, Executive Services, Room G06, Administration Building 3a, Clayton Campus, telephone 9905-2010 or via email to: tony.calder@adm.monash.edu.au