Meeting No. 4/93 of the Monash University Council was held on Monday, 28
June 1993, in the Council Room, University Offices, at the Clayton campus,
between 5.00 pm and 7.30 pm.
Mr D.W. Rogers, Chancellor, in the Chair
Dr G.A. Knights, Deputy Chancellor
Mr P.H. Ramler, Deputy Chancellor
Professor M.I. Logan, Vice-Chancellor and President
Mr J.C. Blyth
Dr F.R. Burden
Ms J.A. Chandler
Professor P.C. Chandler
Dr C.K. Coogan
Associate Professor B.J. Costar
Professor A.R. Edwards
Mr H.A. Grayson
Professor J.M. Hearn
Dr M.E. James
Ms M.G. Keys
Dr J.E. Kolm
Mr W.A. Kricker
Ms R.A. McManamny
Mrs J.M. McPhee
Mr A.H. May
Senator K.C.L. Patterson
Miss D.R. Pizzey
Dr P.K. Rodan
Professor R.H. Snape
Mr T.M. Stiles
Associate Professor J. Strauss
The Hon. Mr Justice R.C. Tadgell
Dr G.M. Vaughan
Dr L.E. Ward
Mr B.J. Weatherson
Professor I.W. Chubb, Deputy Vice-Chancellor
Professor R.J. Pargetter, Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Academic Projects)
Professor P.LeP. Darvall, Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Research)
Professor L.H.T. West, Pro-Vice-Chancellor (International Programs)
Mr P.B. Wade, General Manager
Mr M.D. Watson, Acting Academic Registrar
Mr G.F. Neat, Executive Director, University Development
Ms C.E. Anderson, Advisor to the Vice-Chancellor
| 1.Apologies were received from Professor Melbourne and Mr
Whyte, both of whom had special leave, and from Mr Baker, Professor
Bellamy, Mr Guest, Mr Hall, Mr Hatsell, and Mr Spring. |
|
| 2.Special Leave was granted to |
|
| Mr Grayson and Mr Guest for the 9 August meeting. |
MDW |
| 3.Membership Council noted that the current terms of Mr
Baker, Dr Burden, Ms Chandler, Professor Chandler, Mr Grayson, Dr James,
Mr May, Professor Snape, and Mr Weatherson were due to expire
on 30 June, and that action had been taken or was in hand for the
filling of the vacancies that would arise as a consequence. Council also
noted that Mr Hatsell had submitted his resignation from the
Gippsland Campus Advisory Council as of 22 July and would, as a
consequence, cease to be a member of Council at that time, with the
incoming Chairperson of the Gippsland Campus Advisory Council being
coopted as a member of Council in succession to Mr Hatsell in accordance
with the procedure agreed to at Meeting No. 1/93.
4. Conduct of Business
Items 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, 13, 20, 22, 24, 25, 26, 27, and 28
were discussed at the meeting; the remaining items dealt with en bloc.
|
|
| 5.Minutes |
|
| The minutes of Meeting No. 3/93 held on 17 May, copies of which had
been circulated, were confirmed and signed.
6. Matters Arising from the Minutes
6.1 State Superannuation Scheme Benefits |
|
| The General Manager reported that the measures he had outlined at
the previous meeting had led to the successful preservation of the
superannuation benefits of employee members of the State Superannuation
Scheme, with the Minister having commended the Victorian universities on
their initiative. |
|
| 7.Use of the University Seal |
|
| Council approved the affixing of the University Seal to the appended
list of documents.
8. Queen's Birthday Honours
Council was pleased to note the following awards in the Queen's
Birthday Honours List to persons with links to the University:
. Professor H.G. Burger AO,
Honorary Professor in the Department of Medicine and Director of the
Prince Henry's Institute of Medical Research;
. Emeritus Professor N.E. Carson AO
, former professor and foundation Chairman of the Department of
Community Medicine;
. Professor M.G. Clyne AO
, Department of Linguistics;
. Emeritus Professor D.A. Lowther AM
, former Professor of Biochemistry and Deputy Dean of the Faculty of
Medicine; and
. Ms M.B. Gill OAM
, Senior Lecturer in the Faculty of Education
9. Report of the Vice-Chancellor
9.1 Administrative Arrangements in the Vice-Chancellor's Office
After noting the matters referred to in the appended paper, Council
ratified the action taken by the Vice-Chancellor in appointing Professor
Darvall as Deputy Vice-Chancellor (Research) on a half-time basis until
the end of the year, and approved the position being advertised with a
view to it being filled on a full-time basis as early as possible in
1994. |
|
| Dr Knights observed that the recent turnover of staff in the senior
research portfolio was potentially damaging to the University's research
effort. He suggested it would be timely for an audit to be conducted of
the implementation of the Waller Committee recommendations before the
position was advertised and moved, with Dr Kolm, the establishment of a
small ad hoc committee chaired by the Vice-Chancellor to
undertake this task. Professor Logan said he was not averse to this
suggestion as long as the review was undertaken quickly and as a joint
exercise with the Academic Board. It was left to him to appoint and
chair of small joint committee of Council and Board members to this end. |
MIL |
| 9.2Accident The Vice-Chancellor briefed Council on the
details of an accident that had occurred in the Department of Chemistry
on 2 June which had resulted in serious injury to the right hand of a
senior postgraduate student. He said he was satisfied that emergency
procedures taken at the time had been adequate, and that the initial and
ongoing medical treatment of the student was the best available. The
student was on sick leave with stipend, and would be in receipt of
compensation from the Sports and Recreation Association's student
insurance scheme, he said. The student had also been made aware of his
rights. A committee of inquiry had been established under the
chairmanship of the Dean of the Faculty of Science, Professor Logan
said, and the University was cooperating with action initiated by the
Occupational Health and Safety Authority.
9.3 Planning and Budget
The Vice-Chancellor informed Council that the Academic Board had, at
its last meeting, discussed the academic parameters that would help
shape the University's 1994 budget. Such matters would be under
continuing consideration by the Board and the Committee of Deans, he
said, which would form the basis of further reports to Council.
9.4 General Staff Restructuring Award
Council noted the appended paper.
9.5 Equal Opportunity in Staff Selection |
|
| Council endorsed the staff selection procedures contained in the
appended memorandum from the Vice-Chancellor. In so doing, Council noted
that a broad-ranging review of all the University's staff selection
practices had been commenced by the Deputy Vice-Chancellor which might,
when complete, impinge on these procedures. |
IWC |
| 9.6VIEPS Committee of Management |
|
| Council approved a recommendation from the Vice-Chancellor that
Professor R.A.F. Cas be appointed to succeed Professor G.S. Lister
as a Monash University representative on the Victorian Institute of
Earth and Planetary Sciences Committee of Management. |
MDW |
| 9.7Students from Malaysia The Vice-Chancellor briefed
Council on a potentially embarrassing situation that had arisen for the
University relating to medical education in Malaysia.
9.8 Students in Hong Kong
The Vice-Chancellor informed Council that, as a result of certain
allegations against the agent that Monash and a number of other
Australian universities had been associated with in Hong Kong, all
connections with that agent had been discontinued. Monash was now
dealing direct with the Hong Kong Polytechnic, he said, in regard to its
off-shore courses in Business and Nursing.
9.9 Van Cleef Foundation |
|
| After noting the appended letter to the Vice-Chancellor from the
Dean of the Faculty of Medicine and draft agreement, Council gave its in
principle approval to proceed as recommended by Professor Porter subject
to discussions taking place between the Vice-Chancellor and Mr Kricker
on any matters therein affecting the interests of the Alfred Hospital. |
MIL |
| 9.10Structural Arrangements in the Faculty of Business and
Economics |
|
|
| Council received and generally endorsed the appended paper submitted
by the Deputy Vice-Chancellor setting out amended management
arrangements for the new Faculty of Business and Economics following
consultation he had initiated, as agreed, with individuals and groups
associated with both parties to the merger. In the course of discussion,
it was noted that the only level of management that hadn't been reviewed
was departmental governance, and it was agreed that Professor Chubb
might well look into this and report to Council in due course. |
IWC |
| Council also received the appended report of the Faculty of Business
and Economics Implementation Task Force and noted that, unless directed
to do so by the Vice-Chancellor, it did not plan to meet again apart
from having a wind-up meeting at the end of the year. As requested,
Council approved the Amendments to Schedules to Faculties
Regulations (Faculty of Business and Economics) appended to
the report, subject to the fraction of `0.5' being amended to '0.4'
in the two instances that it occurred in clause 2.2 under subsection 7.2
on page 3 in order to conform with standard practice in the rest of the
University. |
RJP SB |
| 9.11Monash Alumni Council noted the appended paper giving
details of the inception of the Monash University Distinguished
Alumni Awards and a number of programs mounted by the Alumni
Relations and Fundraising Office. The Vice-Chancellor said he felt there
was certainly scope for the alumni to play a more effective role within
the University community. 9.12 30 Collins Street |
|
| Council received the appended paper and, after being briefed by the
General Manager and agreeing to substitute `the University's' for
`its' in the third line of section 8 on page 3, approved the
recommendations therein. |
PBW |
| 9.13China Following recent media coverage, the
Vice-Chancellor briefed Council on a joint venture being entered into
with the University of International Business and Economics in Beijing
which may, among other things, involve the construction of a 22-story
building on the UIBE campus at no cost to Monash. Council noted the
likelihood of more opportunities emerging in China of potential interest
to the University.
10. Report of the Dean of the Faculty of Education
Professor Aspin addressed Council with reference to his appended
paper on the theme of Coping with Change Successfully.
11. Report of the Gippsland Campus Advisory Council |
|
| Council received the appended report and approved the following
recommendation therein: |
CB |
| 11.1Monash Gippsland Union Rules of Incorporation 12.
Report of the Academic Board (Meeting No. 4/93) |
|
| Council received and noted the appended report of the Academic Board
and approved the following recommendations therein: |
JAD |
| 12.1Courses and Degrees (Doctor of Philosophy and Professional
Doctorate Programmes (All Faculties) (Amendment No. 2) Regulations
(1.1); |
|
| 12.2Appointment of Associate Dean in the Faculty of Arts
(2); |
|
| 12.3Appointment of Associate Dean (Research) in the David Syme
Faculty of Business (3); |
|
| 12.4Membership of the Board of the David Syme Faculty of Business
- Appointments to Fill Casual Vacancies (4); |
|
| 12.5Membership of Academic Board - Appointment of Representatives
of the David Syme Faculty of Business to Fill Casual Vacancies
(5); |
|
| 12.6Proposal to Teach Existing Faculty of Business Courses in
Malaysia and Hong Kong - Master of Business (Accounting) and Master of
Practising Accounting
(6); |
|
| 12.7Introduction of Fees for Supplementary Assessment of Students
of a School of Business, Gippsland Course at Hong Kong Polytechnic
(7); |
|
| 12.8Offering of Existing Faculty of Business Courses as
Postgraduate Fee- Paying Courses for Australian Residents - Graduate
Diploma in Marketing and Master of Business (Marketing) (8); and |
|
| 12.9Hire Charges for the Alexander Theatre . |
|
| Council also made the following legislation as contained in the
appended supplementary report of the Academic Board: |
|
| 12.10Courses and Degrees (Faculty of Law) (Amendment No. 36)
Regulations
(1.1). |
|
| 13.Report of the Academic Board (Meeting No. 5/93) |
|
| Council received and noted the appended report of the Academic Board
and approved the following recommendations therein, subject to the
amendments to items 13.1 and 13.2 indicated: |
JAD |
| 13.1Courses and Degrees (Faculty of Medicine) (Degree of
Master of Health Science (Nursing)) Regulations
(1.1), subject to the deletion of `may' in the first line of
clause 4.2.2, and clause 5.2.3 being renumbered 5.3 with the consequent
renumbering of clauses 5.3 and 5.4 to 5.4 and 5.5 respectively; |
|
| 13.2Statute 6.1.2 - Courses and Degrees (Substitution) Statute
(1.2); |
|
| 13.3Statute 2.5 - Committees, Board of Studies and Institute
(Amendment No. 22) Statute (1.3), subject to the deletion of `to'
in the first line of clause 2.2.13, and the insertion of `or the Syme
Graduate Business School' following `Management' in the
second line of clause 3.6.1; |
|
| 13.4Proposal to Introduce Subject Quotas in the Faculty of
Education (2); |
|
| 13.5Proposal to Establish a Science Communications Centre
(3); |
|
| 13.6Appointment of Heads of Departments and Directors of Centres
in the Faculty of Science at the Gippsland Campus (4); |
|
| 13.7Proposal to Establish a Chair of Organisational Behaviour
(5); |
|
| 13.8Appointment of Head of Department of Earth Sciences
(6); |
|
| 13.9Review of the Department of Computer Technology - Faculty of
Computing and Information Technology (7); and |
|
| 13.10Review of the Department of Software Development - Faculty
of Computing and Information Technology (8). |
|
| In addition, the Vice-Chancellor responded to questions in regard to
items 4, 6, and 7 of the Proceedings in the Board's report. In response
to another question, the Deputy Vice- Chancellor confirmed that the
Monash Association of Students and the Monash University Student Union
Inc. would be consulted in regard to the appointment of the two student
members of the Undergraduate Education Committee referred to in item 9
of the Proceedings. 14.Report of the Biosafety Committee
Council received and noted the appended report of the Biosafety
Committee. |
|
| 15.Report of the Buildings Committee Council received and
noted the appended report of the Buildings Committee. |
|
| 16.Report of the Executive Committee Council noted that on,
16 June, the Executive Committee, by way of a postal ballot of its
members conducted in accordance with the provisions of its constitution,
had approved a recommendation from the Vice-Chancellor that it ratify
decisions taken by the Academic Board between 8 May 1991 and the
present, in the light of technical problems associated with the terms of
office of some members of the Board during that period, as reported to
Council at its previous meeting. |
|
| 17.Reports of the Finance Committee and the Trustees of the
Monash University Foundation Council received and noted the
appended report of the Finance Committee. Council also received and
noted the appended report of the Trustees of the Monash University
Foundation. 18. Report of the Naming Committee |
|
| Council received the appended report of the Naming Committee and
approved the following recommendation therein: |
BML |
| 18.1Naming of the New Public Lecture Theatre Council also
amended the wording of the recommendation it approved at Meeting No.
2/93 by including the words `and Medicine' following `Centre
for Molecular Biology' that were inadvertently omitted from the
proposed new title for Block B of the Medical School on the Clayton
campus; the correct name being `Centre for Molecular Biology and
Medicine - H & L Hecht Wing
'. |
AWL |
| 19.Report of the Nominations Committee |
|
| Council received and noted the appended report of the Nominations
Committee. |
|
| 20.Report of the Occupational Health and Safety Policy Committee
Council received the appended report of the Occupational Health and
Safety Policy Committee and approved the following recommendation
therein:
20.1 Committee Composition
. |
CT |
| 21.Report of the Patents Committee Council received and
noted the appended report of the Patents Committee, including the
accompanying 1992 annual report. |
RB |
|
|
| 22.Reports of Chair Selection Committees Council approved
offers of appointment being made as recommended in the appended reports
of selection committees in respect of the following positions: |
BRM |
| 22.1Chair of Business Accounting ; and
22.2 Chair of General Practice
. 23. Report of the Union Board |
|
| Council received the appended report of the Union Board and approved
the following recommendations therein: |
CH |
| 23.1 Constitutional Amendment - MPA Nominee on Union Board
; and
23.2 Monash Bookshop Rental
. 24. Report on Chair Appointments |
|
| Council received the appended paper and appointed the selection
committees as recommended therein together with Council representatives
as follows:
24.1 Chair of Computing, Software Development
Mrs McPhee and Dr Vaughan;
24.2 Chair of Public Sector Management
Ms Chandler and Dr Rodan; and
24.3 Chair of Structural Engineering
Ms Keys and Dr Ward.
25. Gender Representation on Decision-Making Bodies |
|
| Council approved the setting in train, for itself and for its
standing and ad hoc committees, a review of membership in regard
to gender balance as provided for in the appended policy on gender
representation on decision-making bodies approved by Council at its
previous meeting. To this end, it was agreed that the Secretary should,
in the first instance, refer the matter of the gender balance of Council
to the Nominations Committee for consideration and report, and ask the
Secretaries of Council's standing committees to have the policy listed
for discussion and report at their next convenient meetings. |
MDW |
| 26.Legislation In accordance with the advice of the
University Solicitor's Office, Council made the following legislation,
copies of which are appended: |
SB |
|
|
| 26.1Courses and Degrees (Faculty of Education) (Degree of
Master of Special Education) Regulations ; and |
|
| 26.2Administrative Review Statute 1993 , subject to
the substitution of `oral' for `verbal' in the first line
of clause 1.1.4. |
|
| 27.Supplementary Trust Deed |
|
| In accordance with the appended advice of the Senior Assistant
Solicitor, Council made the appended supplementary deed to the Monash
University `M' Superannuation Scheme, subject to its referral to and
approval by the Superannuation Scheme Trustees. |
VPC |
| 28.Institute of Reproduction and Development Council
deferred the appointment of a nominee on the Advisory Board of the
University's Institute of Reproduction and Development pending the
receipt of advice from the Vice-Chancellor on the gender balance of the
Board's current membership. |
MDW |
| 29.Appointment of Secretary to the Academic Board |
|
| In accordance with section 4 of Statute 2.2 - The Academic Board,
Council appointed the Manager of the University Secretariat, Ms J.A.
Dunn, as Secretary to the Academic Board. |
JAD |
| 30.Reports on Outside Studies Programs and Overseas Leave
Council received and noted the appended reports from: |
|
| 30.1 Dr I.A.E. Bayly, Department of Ecology and Evolutionary
Biology; 30.2 Dr J.L. Bradshaw, Department of Psychology; |
|
| 30.3 Dr I. Campbell, Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology; |
|
| 30.4 Dr M.N. Clayton, Department of Ecology and Evolutionary
Biology; |
|
| 30.5 Associate Professor B.J. Costar, Department of Politics; |
|
| 30.6 Associate Professor J.P. Cull, Department of Earth Sciences; |
|
| 30.7 Dr G.B. Deacon, Department of Chemistry; |
|
| 30.8 Dr M.J. Englefield, Department of Mathematics; |
|
| 30.9 Associate Professor T.R. Finlayson, Department of Physics; |
|
| 30.10 Dr P.C. Gronn, School of Graduate Studies, Faculty of
Education; |
|
| 30.11 Mr P.G. Heffey, Faculty of Law; |
|
| 30.12 Dr S.G. Loo, Department of Mathematics; |
|
| 30.13 Dr C.B.G. McIntosh, Department of Mathematics; |
|
| 30.14 Professor W.R.A. Muntz, Department of Ecology and Evolutionary
Biology; |
|
| 30.15 Dr J.E. Nelson, Department of Ecology and Evolutionary
Biology; |
|
| 30.16 Dr M.A. Page, Department of Mathematics; |
|
| 30.17 Ms M.J. Pittard, Faculty of Law; |
|
| 30.18 Mr W.M. Richardson, Syme School of Accounting; |
|
| 30.19 Dr A. Simon, Syme School of Management; |
|
| 30.20 Dr D.A. Smith, Department of Physics; |
|
| 30.21 Professor G.C. Smith, Department of Psychological Medicine; |
|
| 30.22 Professor A.O. Trounson, Institute of Reproduction and
Development; and |
|
| 30.23 Associate Professor I.D.S. Ward, Department of Economics. |
|
| 31.Next Meeting Members were reminded that the next meeting
of Council was scheduled to be held at 5.00 pm on Monday, 9 August, in
the Council Room on the Clayton Campus. |
|