Council Meeting 4/2001
Meeting No. 4/2001 of the Monash University Council was
held between 5.00 pm and 7.20 pm on Monday, 25 June 2001, in the
Clayfield Room, Administration Building, Caulfield Campus
There were present:
Mr J K Ellis,
Presiding
Mr P H Ramler
AM, Deputy Chancellor
Dr J M Hearn,
Deputy Chancellor
Professor D A
Robinson, Vice-Chancellor and President
Professor A W
Lindsay, Chair of Academic Board
|
Associate Professor L
Adler
Mr G Barnes
Ms M Blencowe
Professor C Bourke MBE
Ms D Halstead
Mr J Hutchinson
|
Dr P James
Mr J Laurie
Ms W Peter
Miss D R Pizzey AM
Professor T Sridhar
Ms E Tava |
In attendance were:
Professor P LeP
Darvall, Deputy Vice-Chancellor and Vice-President (Research and
Development)
Ms A Crook AO,
Deputy Vice-Chancellor and Vice-President (Resources)
Professor S
Parker, Dean, Faculty of Law
Professor H Le
Grand, Dean, Faculty of Arts
Mr J Matthews,
Divisional Director, Corporate Finance
Mr J White,
Campus Director, Caulfield/Peninsula Campuses
Ms S Heron,
Specialist Advisor Strategy and Commercial, Office of Deputy
Vice-Chancellor and Vice-President (Resources)
Ms S Stafford,
Executive Officer for Deputy Vice-Chancellor and Vice-President
(Academic and Planning)
Mr T Calder,
University Secretariat
Secretary:
Mr P Siggins, Manager, University Secretariat
MINUTES
PART A
1. PROCEDURAL MATTERS
1.1 Apologies
An apology was received from Dr Mark Schapper.
1.2 Special Leave
At Council meeting 3/2001 (7 May), Council approved a
request for special leave for meeting 4/2001 (25 June) for the
Chancellor. However, the Chancellor was present for this meeting.
Council approved requests for special leave from this
meeting for Ms Ann Sherry and Ms Penelope Hutchinson.
1.3 Starring of Items
Items 1.1 Apologies, 1.2 Special Leave,
1.3 Starring of Items, 1.4 Approval of Non-Starred Items,
1.5.1 Vice-Chancellor’s Issues and Speculation, 2 Confirmation
of Minutes of Previous Meeting, 3 Chancellor’s Business, 4
Vice-Chancellor’s Business 6.1 Victorian Partnership for Advanced
Computing Limited, 7.1 Biocom International Ltd, 7.3
Proceedings of the Resources and Finance Committee (specifically
Accountability Reports and IAS Progress Report), 8.3.1 Proposal
to establish and fill the position of Professor of Early
Childhood/Primary Education, 8.3.3 Proposal to establish and fill
a Chair of Accounting, Monash South Africa, 9.1 Equal Opportunity
Committee Receipt of Report, 11.1.2 Professor of General
Practice – Appointment, 11.1.4 Chair of Pharmacy Practice –
Appointment and 11.1.5 The Sir Keith Aickin Chair of Company Law
- Appointment were starred and discussed at this meeting.
1.4 Approval of Non-Starred Items
Council resolved on the motion of the Chancellor:
‘that all items on the agenda not starred be adopted
without discussion, and the action recommended be taken or the
information therein noted’.
1.5 Confidential Items
1.5.1 Vice-Chancellor’s Issues and Speculations
The Vice-Chancellor spoke to this item and reported on
progress with developments concerning the University and three sporting
organisations.
1.5.2 Report of the Membership Committee
1.5.2.1 Receipt of Report
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/87
Council received and noted the report of meeting 1/2001
of the Membership Committee of Council held on Monday, 4 June 2001.
(File RMO1997/1107)
1.5.2.2 Vacancies on Council for 2002
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/88
Council noted that Membership Committee gave preliminary
consideration to filling of vacancies on Council for 2002 and would
bring nominations to Council meeting 6/2001 (1 October).
(Files RMO1997/1274, RMO1997/1111, RMO1998/2753,
RMO1998/2752)
For action or noting by: Secretary to Membership
Committee
1.5.2.3 Filling of current vacancies on Council
Committees
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/89
Council approved the appointments of members to the
vacancies on Council Committees as detailed below:
Executive Committee
Professor Tam Sridhar
Alternate
Ms Dale Halstead
For action or noting by: Secretary to Executive
Committee
Membership Committee
Professor Tam Sridhar
For action or noting by: Secretary to Membership
Committee
Resources and Finance Committee
Dr Paul James
For action or noting by: Secretary and Minute Secretary
to Resources and Finance Committee
Physical Resources Subcommittee
Mr Jerry Ellis
Professor Tam Sridhar
For action or noting by: Secretary to Physical Resources
Subcommittee
Honorary Degrees Committee (a joint Committee of Council
and Academic Board)
Professor Colin Bourke MBE
For action or noting by: Secretary to Honorary Degrees
Committee
(Files RMO1998/0046, RMO1998/0045, RMO1998/0041,
RMO1998/0039, RMO1998/0220)
1.5.3 Use of the University Seal
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/90
Council noted the report of the Vice-Chancellor dated 13
June 2001 on the affixing of the Common Seal to documents executed under
Seal pursuant to Statute 8.1, Section 2.1.5.
(File RMO1997/0889)
For action or noting by: University Solicitor
1.6 Admission of Observers
Authorised observers were admitted to the meeting
following confidential items.
2. Confirmation of Minutes of Previous Meeting
The Minutes of meeting No 3/2001 held on 7 May 2001 were
circulated subject to Minute 8.4 Monash University Global Equal
Opportunity Policy being amended to include the following:
"A member requested that the Monash University Global
Equal Opportunity Policy include as represented groups rural and
isolated students and students adversely affected by low socio economic
status. The Chairman of the Equal Opportunity Committee acceded to the
request."
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/91
Council confirmed the Minutes of meeting No. 3/2001 held
on Monday, 7 May 2001 subject to the amendment as detailed above.
PART B STARRED ITEMS
3. Chancellor’s Business
3.1 Retirement of Council Secretary
The Chancellor informed Council that Mr Phillip Siggins
was retiring as Secretary to Council having served in this capacity for
four years. The Chancellor noted that Mr Siggins’ career included twenty
years of work at Monash and requested that the Minutes record Council’s
appreciation for Mr Siggins’ service.
The Chancellor also informed Council of the appointment
of Mr Tony Calder as Director, Secretariat and Executive Services who
will fill the position of Secretary to Council from August 2001. The
Chancellor congratulated Mr Calder on his appointment.
3.2 Synchrotron
The Chancellor advised that he had written to the
Premier of Victoria extending his congratulations on the initiative and
vision of the Victorian Government in establishing this national
synchrotron facility at the University. The establishment of the
synchrotron at Monash reflected well on the University and was an
indicator of its high status within the community and the excellence of
its reputation.
Deputy Chancellor Paul Ramler reported on the launch of
the Monash Science Technology Research and Innovation Precinct (The
Monash STRIP) and spoke of the Minister’s excellent presentation, which
encompassed Victoria’s vision for the future, and the place of Monash in
that vision.
The Vice-Chancellor also commented that the launch of
The Monash STRIP had contributed to the environment which facilitated
the establishment of the synchrotron at Monash. These developments
represented a major vote of confidence in the future of the University
and represented a "coming of age" of the University which now held a
central position in the community.
Deputy Vice-Chancellor and Vice-President (Research and
Development) Professor Peter Darvall spoke of the history of
developments leading to the establishment of the synchrotron and
commented that this successful outcome was produced by the coalescence
of numerous endeavours and circumstances. Professor Darvall suggested
that optimism should be tempered by an awareness of the challenges
facing the establishment of the project.
In concluding this item, the Chancellor, on behalf of
Council, extended congratulations to the Vice-Chancellor, Professor
Darvall and all involved in the project.
For action or noting by: Deputy Vice-Chancellor and
Vice-President (Research and Development), Manager, Office of the
Vice-Chancellor and President
4. Vice-Chancellor’s Business
4.1 Queen’s Birthday Honours
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/92
Council noted with acclamation Queen’s Birthday Honours
awarded to the individuals associated with Monash as follows:
AO (Officer of the Order of Australia)
Professor Allan Fels
For service to Australian competition policy through the
development and regulation of trade practices and to consumer
protection, and to public education in relation to consumer law and its
implications for business and commerce
Dr Hilary McPhee (DLitt 1992)
For service to the arts, particularly as a promoter of
Australian writers and as a literary publisher, and to arts
administration through the Australia Council
Professor John Mattick (PhD Sci 1978)
For service to scientific research in the fields of
molecular biology, genetics and biotechnology, particularly through the
development and administration of research institutes and the Australian
Genome Research Facility
Professor Paul Zimmet AM (PhD Med 1973)
For service to medical research of national and
international significance, particularly in the field of diabetes, as a
leader of investigations into social, nutritional and lifestyle
diseases, and to biotechnology development in Australia
AM (Member of the Order of Australia)
Associate Professor Elizabeth Dax (PhD Med 1977)
For service to medical research, particularly in the
fields of public health, HIV/AIDS and drug addiction.
Dr Penelope Egan-Vine (MB,BS 1970)
For service to the community of the Albury/Wodonga
region, particularly through the development and expansion of support
services and counselling groups for people in crisis.
Dr Geoffrey Metz (MB,BS w/hons 1970, MD 1979)
For service to medicine as a consultant physician, to
the development of medical services, medical education and training
facilities, and through medical administration and health-care delivery.
Father Mark Raper SJ (BA 1969)
For service to international humanitarian relief through
the Jesuit Refugee Service.
AM (Member of the Order of Australia) – military
division
Commodore Mervyn Davis (MBA (Mt Eliza) 1994)For
exceptional service to the Royal Australian Navy in the fields of
project management and capability management.
Group Captain Clive Rossiter (BE 1978, GradDipAcc&Fin
1983)
For exceptional service to the Royal Australian Air
Force as the Director of the Tactical Fighter Systems Project Office.
OAM (Medal of the Order of Australia)
Sister Rosemary Crumlin (MA 1985)
For service to the visual arts, particularly the
promotion and understanding of contemporary religious art, to education
and to the community.
Professor Jock Findlay
For service to medicine as a researcher, particularly in
the field of reproductive biology, and as a medical administrator.
Ms Nanette Green (PhC 1957, GradDipHospitalPharm
1982)
For service to the community of Wangaratta through
health, educational, historical and women’s groups.
Dr Srechko Kontelj (BEc 1983, LLB 1989, LLM 1989)
For service to multiculturalism in Geelong, particularly
through the Geelong Migrant Resource Centre, and to local government.
PSM (Public Service Medal)
Dr John Morris (MAdmin 1981)
For outstanding public service to hospital planning and
administration particularly for innovation in the area of cancer
services.
(File RMO1999/0190)
4.2 Key topics of Vice-Chancellor’s Business: meetings 04/2001 to
08/2001
A paper, Key topics of Vice-Chancellor’s Business:
meetings 04/2001 to 08/2001 had been circulated. The Vice-Chancellor
introduced the paper noting that the schedule of key topics represented
a challenging list of business to be dealt with before the year
concluded.
Members congratulated the Vice-Chancellor on the
interesting breadth and depth of topics and additional topics were also
suggested. A member suggested that consideration be given to the topic
of political parties and their policies regarding funding of higher
education and that it would be timely if some analysis of these policies
could be provided before the Federal election. Members noted that the
uncertainty about the timing of the election was a factor but the
Vice-Chancellor recognised the importance of the topic for discussion in
the second half of the year and suggested that all things being equal,
this matter be scheduled for Council meeting 6/2001 (1 October).
Another member suggested that consideration might be
given to discussion of priorities concerning learning and teaching in
the University and clarified that this topic might address how balances
might be achieved between different sectors and discipline areas within
the University. These balances might be exemplified, for example, in the
dualities of arts versus science and applied versus theoretical
knowledge. The Vice-Chancellor advised that this sort of issue should be
discussed by the Academic Board in the first instance and could be
considered by Council in the first of two papers from Professor Lindsay
in 2002 providing "slices through" the academic profile of the
University. In this discussion, it was agreed that the first
"discussion" meeting of Council for 2002 might consider the self-review
of the University which is to be conducted in the second half of 2001.
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/93
Council noted the schedule of Key topics of
Vice-Chancellor’s Business: meetings 04/2001 to 08/2001 and approved
the additional topics as detailed above.
For action or noting by: Secretary to Council, Manager,
Office of the Vice-Chancellor and President, Secretary to Academic
Board, Executive Officer to Deputy Vice-Chancellor and Vice-President
(Academic and Planning)
4.3 Monash in Europe: London and Prato
Council received the following papers:
-
Monash in Europe: London and Prato;
-
Monash in London Future Directions
Report Academic Board – 6 June 2001 University Council 25 June 2001;
-
Monash in Prato Future Directions
Report Academic Board – 6 June 2001 University Council 25 June 2001;
-
Extract from the Australian (23 May
2001) "Italian Palace of Ideas"; and
-
London and Prato – Combined finances
for the initial three years.
Professor Stephen Parker, Dean, Faculty of Law and
Professor Homer Le Grand, Dean, Faculty of Arts spoke to this item.
Professor Parker provided a brief background on Monash
in Europe and London and introduced the presentation on Monash in
London. Professor Parker indicated that the planning for London had
ended its first phase and the Pro Vice-Chancellor London had dealt with
negotiations at the highest level and settled a range of matters with
King’s College and promoted the Monash presence. Future arrangements
included a part time Director for London and a full time Manager for
London. There would be increasing movement on student and staff
exchanges, and double-badged programs with King’s were being negotiated.
Sound foundations had been laid.
Professor Le Grand introduced the presentation on Monash
in Prato and emphasised that Monash was fortunate in developing Prato
under the guidance of a particularly suitable leader, Professor Bill
Kent. The timing of this initiative had been advantageous insofar as the
Italian economy was robust; the European Union was turning to Asia and
looking to Monash for its Asian connections. Prato itself was
geographically central and convenient as Monash’s window onto Europe.
Professor Parker drew together the presentations
advising that intensive planning activities in respect of Europe had
been undertaken recently and that planning was now proceeding on an
integrated basis for Europe as a whole. It was now proposed that a
single Europe Steering Committee would be created before the end of 2001
to take over from the separate London and Prato Committees and provide a
broader approach.
Members commented on the proposal for double degrees as
outlined in Professor Parker’s presentation and a member noted that the
double-badged degree offered by the Faculty of Engineering and
University of Manchester might provide a suitable model. In response to
a member, Professor Parker clarified that the Menzies Centre was
constitutionally part of King’s College and part of the School of
Humanities at King’s. Professor Parker also confirmed that Monash in
London and Prato were separately funded and that separate financial
reports would be presented to Resources and Finance Committee and then
to Council in due course. Council members noted the generous benefaction
of $1 million for three years in support of Monash in Europe. The
Vice-Chancellor also clarified developments in Germany noting that the
Centre for Australian Studies as established by Prime Minister Paul
Keating would relocate from Potsdam to Berlin and that Monash would be
one of four participating universities which would include the
Australian National University, the University of Sydney and the
University of New South Wales.
The Chancellor extended his thanks to Professors Parker
and Le Grand for their presentations.
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/94
Council received and noted the report on Monash in
Europe: London and Prato as presented by Professor Stephen Parker,
Dean, Faculty of Law and Professor Homer Le Grand, Dean, Faculty of
Arts.
(File RMO2001/0640, RMO2000/0879)
4.4 Course Structures for Professional and Employment Needs
In introducing the paper, Course Structures for
Professional and Employment Needs, the Vice-Chancellor explained
that the body of the paper was for discussion but that Appendix A, which
detailed specific faculty responses, should be reserved for informal
discussion.
Professor Alan Lindsay, Deputy Vice-Chancellor and
Vice-President (Academic and Planning) then spoke to the paper. In his
opening remarks, Professor Lindsay advised that follow up to the first
of his reports on the "development of the curriculum and engagement with
stakeholders" would be presented to Council toward the end of 2001.
Professor Lindsay took Council through the paper and
reported that this presentation on ‘course structures for professional
and employment needs’ showed that:
-
all faculties had engaged in major and
ongoing restructuring of the course offerings in which they had made
effective use of the available types of course and award structures in
response to changing community and employment needs;
-
cross-faculty single and double awards
and cross-institutional awards were an area of considerable further
potential for development by Monash; and
-
the post-graduate award structure and
its articulation in professional and research streams warranted
further consideration in terms of appropriateness for the current
diverse needs of local and international communities and labour
markets.
Professor Lindsay also noted that Academic Board at its
meeting on 6 June 2001 agreed that further consideration by the
University Education Committee be given to cross-faculty and
cross-institutional awards and that a special Academic Board working
party be established to consider further restructuring of the
post-graduate award.
Professor Lindsay commended the paper to Council.
A member raised questions about the issue of the length
of masters by coursework degrees and suggested that a program of 24
points at 5th year level effectively halved the amount of
work done. Another member also expressed concern at masters programs
being only 24 points and suggested that residency requirements should be
introduced. In response, Professor Lindsay advised that no masters
programs at Monash required less than 48 credit points and that the
standard requirement was 72 points. He also made reference to that in a
previous era, universities operated as an elite system and only a small
number of students undertook masters degrees. But the context was now
one of mass education and there were continuing inconsistencies in
relation to honours and consequently in relation to entry into
postgraduate work. Masters programs were now available in a diverse
range of formats and entry was more complex with multiple entry points.
Professor Lindsay also made the point that in this context the notion of
the "5th year level" was not always an appropriate one to
use. He also made reference to the importance of developments
internationally in relation to masters degrees and in particular pointed
to the difficulties in relation to defining graduate and postgraduate
diplomas in comparison with our competitor systems such as the British
model where the English model was at variance with the Scottish model.
Hence, Council needed to be aware that Monash was operating in an
ambiguous environment where terms that were apparently identical had
different meanings.
The Chancellor rounded off discussion noting the points
made by the members who had expressed concerns and advising that this
was a matter for Academic Board to debate and provide advice to Council.
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/95
Council received and noted the report on course
structures for professional and employment needs as presented by
Professor Alan Lindsay, Deputy Vice-Chancellor and Vice-President
(Academic and Planning).
(File RMO2000/0611)
For action or noting by: Executive Officer to Deputy
Vice-Chancellor and Vice-President (Academic and Planning)
4.5 The Monash Science Technology Research and Innovation Precinct
"The Monash STRIP"
Ms Alison Crook, Deputy Vice-Chancellor and
Vice-President (Resources) spoke to this item.
Ms Crook took members through the paper, The Monash
Science Technology Research and Innovation Precinct "The Monash STRIP"
emphasising the concept of The STRIP which would provide a
multi-disciplinary focus for the University, business and industry to
work together forming one of Australia’s largest aggregations of
researchers.
Ms Crook also drew attention to the pressures for
additional accommodation that had been growing on the Clayton Campus for
a number of years. Ms Crook noted that planning for The STRIP would
proceed over a ten-year period and would be built in five stages and
that the financial arrangements reflected this staged process.
In addressing the funding arrangements, Ms Crook advised
Council that the paper before them was a strategy paper and not a
detailed cash flow paper and she amended the last sentence on page 4,37
to read "The construction cost for completion to shell and fit out for
the 50% of the space used by the faculties is $43.6 million." The
pressure on space was such that the University would be in a strong
position to lease space immediately. Ms Crook concluded her presentation
by noting that the concept was one that capitalised on and leveraged the
intellectual capital of the University and aimed to bring in additional
resources to the University to meet its academic purposes.
Discussion ensued and matters raised by members included
provision for disabled people, consultation with the wider community,
student and staff input (the Vice-Chancellor indicated that this could
be accommodated when user groups were established), whether the cost of
the car park facilities had been taken into account and the balance of
faculty representation in The STRIP.
(Secretarial note: minute 7.3 Proceedings of the
Resources and Finance Committee refers)
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/96
Council received and noted the report on The Monash
Science Technology Research and Innovation Precinct "The Monash STRIP".
(File RMO2001/0569)
For action or noting by: Deputy Vice-Chancellor and
Vice-President (Resources), Divisional Director, Corporate Finance,
Divisional Director, Facilities and Services, Specialist Advisor
Strategy and Commercial, Office of Deputy Vice-Chancellor and
Vice-President (Resources)
PART C ITEMS FOR APPROVAL OR INFORMATION
5. Matters Arising from the Minutes (not dealt with elsewhere in the
agenda)
5.1 Monash International Pty Ltd Business Plan
Minute 7.3 Proceedings of the Resources and Finance
Committee refers. Members noted the withdrawal of the proposal as
discussed at meeting 3/2001 of Council.
(File RMO1997/0356)
5.2 Legislation
Statute 6.3 – Exclusion for Health Reasons (Amendment No 1, 2001)
Statute 6.2 – Exclusion for Unsatisfactory Progress and Exclusion for
Unsatisfactory Progress (Substitution) Regulations
At meeting 3/2001 (7 May), it was agreed that
clarification of aspects of legislation Statute 6.3 and Statute 6.2 and
Regulations pursuant to Statute 6.2 would be sought and consideration
would be deferred until this meeting of Council.
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/97
Noting that the original decisions were to devolve the
Exclusion for Unsatisfactory Progress process to the faculties and to
preserve student equity in the exclusion processes, Council:
-
established a small working group to
give further consideration to the draft enabling legislation in
relation to these matters comprising Associate Professor John Hurst,
Ms Manisha Blencowe, a representative from the Office of the
University Solicitor and any other member(s) so identified by the
Deputy Vice-Chancellor and Vice-President (Academic and Planning); and
-
requested the small working group so
established to report its findings to Council via the Deputy
Vice-Chancellor and Vice-President (Academic and Planning).
(File RMO1999/1767, RMO2001/0500)
For action or noting by: Deputy Vice-Chancellor
and Vice-President (Academic and Planning), Professor Merran
Evans, Associate Professor John Hurst, Ms Manisha Blencowe, University
Solicitor, Executive Officer to Deputy Vice-Chancellor and
Vice-President (Academic and Planning)
6. Report of the Executive Committee
6.1 Victorian Partnership for Advanced Computing Limited
Council noted that the Executive Committee of Council,
acting under its delegation from Council, met on 10 May 2001 and:
1) authorized the alteration of the Constitution of
Victorian Partnership for Advanced Computing Limited by the deletion of
clause 53.6E "The Accounts of the company shall be audited annually by
the Auditor-General"; and
2) appointed Professor Peter LeP Darvall as the
Representative of Monash University for the purposes of clause 9 of the
Constitution of Victorian Partnership for Advanced Computing Limited.
A member requested clarification of the alteration of
the Constitution of the Company leading to the deletion of Clause 53.6E
as detailed above. This matter was partially clarified at the meeting by
a member of the Executive Committee. (Secretarial note: subsequent to
the meeting, the following advice was supplied by the Office of the
University Solicitor:
"Section 301 of the Corporations Law requires all
companies to have their annual reports audited. It is not necessary to
include this requirement in the Constitution of the company. The
requirement in clause 53.6E of the Constitution of Victorian Partnership
for Advanced Computing Limited for the accounts of the company to be
audited annually by the Auditor-General was mistakenly included.
Although section 35B(8) of the Monash University Act 1958 requires the
accounts of a limited company to be audited annually by the
Auditor-general, this provision is restricted to those limited companies
in which the University has a controlling interest. A similar provision
exists in the Acts establishing all other Victorian Universities. In
this case, the shareholders of the company are several Victorian
Universities (including Monash University), none of which individually
holds a controlling interest. The deletion of the provision from the
company’s Constitution does not in any way reduce the requirement for
the accounts of the company to be audited annually."
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/98
Council noted the approval granted by the Executive
Committee of Council at its meeting held on 10 May 2001.
(File RMO2001/0474)
7. Report of the Resources and Finance Committee
7.1 Biocom International Ltd
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/99
Council approved the directorships as detailed below:
-
Monash staff on the Board of Biocom
International Pty Ltd:
-
Professor David de Kretser (Professor Alan Trounson
as alternate)
-
Professor Napier Thomson (Professor Ban-Hock Toh as
alternate)
-
Associate Professor Graham Jenkin (Professor Bevyn
Jarrott as alternate)
-
Dr Robert Medcalf (Dr Paul Coughlin as alternate)
-
Professor Nick Saunders, Dean of the
Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences as a director of
Biocom Services Pty Ltd
(File RMO2001/0364)
For action or noting by: Deputy Vice-Chancellor and
Vice-President (Research and Development), Deputy Vice-Chancellor and
Vice-President (Resources), Divisional Director, Corporate Finance,
Professor David de Kretser, Professor Alan Trounson,
Professor Napier Thomson, Professor Ban-Hock Toh, Associate Professor
Graham Jenkin, Professor Bevyn Jarrott, Dr Robert Medcalf, Dr Paul
Coughlin, Professor Nick Saunders, Dean of the Faculty of Medicine,
Nursing and Health Sciences
7.2 Statement of Income and Expenditure of Compulsory Amenities Fees
for the Year Ended 31 December 2000 and 2000 Annual Financial Report of
the Student Organisations
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/100
Council approved the report presented for submission to
the Director of the Office of Employment, Training and Tertiary
Education.
(File RMO2000/1252)
For action or noting by: Secretary to Council, Minute
Secretary to Resources and Finance Committee
7.3 Proceedings of the Resources and Finance Committee
Council members were invited to refer to section 2 of
the Resources and Finance Committee Report and noted the proceedings of
the Committee. Items included:
-
Monash International Pty Ltd Business
Plan (Secretarial note: minute 5.1 Monash International Pty Ltd
Business Plan refers)
-
Monash International Pty Ltd Reporting
-
Monash Science Technology Research and
Innovation Precinct (Secretarial note: minute 4.5 The Monash
Science Technology Research and Innovation Precinct "The Monash
STRIP"refers)
-
Structure of Resources and Finance
Committee and its Sub-Committees
-
Accountability Reports 2000 for
University Foundations
A member, while acknowledging progress was made,
suggested that further standardisation of the reports was required.
In response to a member’s question about the training
costs detailed in the report, the Divisional Director, Corporate
Finance, explained that increased training costs had resulted from a
policy decision not to allow access to SAP without personnel being
appropriately trained. The member also requested a review of the "cost
of the benefits introduced". This request was not supported by any
motion in its favour.
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/101
Council noted the proceedings of the Resources and
Finance Committee as detailed in the document presented.
(File RMO1999/1488)
For action or noting by: Secretary and Minute Secretary
to Resources and Finance Committee
8. Report of the Academic Board
8.1 Receipt of Report
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/102
Council received and noted the Report of meeting 3/2001
of the Academic Board held on Wednesday, 6 June 2001.
(File RMO2001/0552)
8.2 Legislation
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/103
Council made the legislation titled Statute 2.3 – The
Faculties (Amendment No 1 2001).
(File RMO1997/1504)
For action or noting by: Deans and Director of
Administration/Faculty Managers/Acting Faculty Managers/Registrar/Acting
Registrar/Head of Administration/Director of Academic Programs – all
faculties, University Solicitor
8.3 Academic Appointments
8.3.1 Proposal to establish and fill the position of Professor of
Early Childhood/Primary Education (Secretarial note: minute
11.1.6.3 of the Report of Senior Appointments refers)
A member requested information on the filling of the
position at Peninsula and was advised that this was a matter for the
Dean of the Faculty of Education.
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/104
Council approved the proposal of the Board of the
Faculty of Education to establish and fill the position of Professor of
Early Childhood / Primary Education.
(File Personnel)
For action or noting by: Dean and Faculty Registrar –
Education, Manager, Senior Appointments
8.3.2 Proposal to rename the Sir Keith Aickin Chair of Commercial Law
to the Sir Keith Aickin Chair of Company Law and fill the position (Secretarial
note: minute 11.1.5 of the Report of Senior Appointments refers)
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/105
Council approved the proposal of the Board of the
Faculty of Law to rename the existing Sir Keith Aickin of Commercial Law
to the Sir Keith Aickin of Company Law and fill the position.
(File Personnel)
For action or noting by: Dean and Faculty Manager – Law,
Manager, Senior Appointments
8.3.3 Proposal to establish and fill a Chair of Accounting, Monash
South Africa (Secretarial note: minute 11.1.6.1 of the Report of
Senior Appointments refers)
A member requested information concerning the brevity of
the documentation for this position and was advised that the
establishment of the position was essential for accreditation of
accounting courses to be offered in South Africa.
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/106
Council approved the proposal of the Board of the
Faculty of Business and Economics to establish and fill a Chair of
Accounting at Monash South Africa.
(File Personnel)
For action or noting by: Pro Vice-Chancellor, Monash
South Africa, Dean and Director of Administration, Business and
Economics, Head of School of Business and Commerce, South Africa,
Manager, Senior Appointments
8.3.4 Proposal to establish and fill a Chair of Strategic Business
Systems (Secretarial note: minute 11.1.6.4 of the Report of
Senior Appointments refers)
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/107
Council approved the proposal of the Board of the
Faculty of Information Technology to establish and fill a Chair of
Strategic Business Systems.
(File Personnel)
For action or noting by: Dean and Acting Faculty Manager
– Information Technology, Manager, Senior Appointments
8.3.5 Proposal to establish and fill the position of Professor (or
Associate Professor) of Australian Indigenous Studies and Director of
the Centre for Australian Indigenous Studies (Secretarial note:
minute 11.1.6.2 of the Report of Senior Appointments refers)
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/108
Council approved the proposal to establish and fill the
position of Professor (or Associate Professor) of Australian Indigenous
Studies and Director of the Centre for Australian Indigenous Studies.
(File Personnel)
For action or noting by: Dean and Faculty Manager –
Arts, Manager, Senior Appointments
8.4 Change of Name – School of Biological Sciences
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/109
Council approved the proposal of the Board of the
Faculty of Science to rename the Department of Biological Sciences to
the School of Biological Sciences.
(File RMO1998/0430)
For action or noting by: Dean and Acting Faculty Manager
– Science, University Solicitor
8.5 Faculty Board Membership – External Members
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/110
Council approved the proposal of the Board of the
Faculty of Law to renew the membership for each of the following
external members of the Board, under University Regulations Part III –
Faculty Boards, Schedule 7, subsection 7.6:
-
The Hon Mr Justice David Harper (to
April 2004)
-
The Hon Justice Susan Kenny (to April
2003)
-
Mr Kevin Pose (to April 2003)
-
The Hon Justice Mark Weinberg (to April
2004)
(File RMO1999/1027)
For action or noting by: Dean and Faculty Manager - Law
8.6 Doctor of Medicine
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/111
Council approved the proposal of the Board of the
Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences to award the degree of
Doctor of Medicine to Dr Kelly-Anne Phillips.
(File RMO1998/0448)
For action or noting by: Dean and Director of Academic
Programs – Medicine, Nursing & Health Sciences, Manager, Graduations
8.7 Establishment of the International Institute of Forensic Studies
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/112
Council approved the proposal of the Faculty of Law to
establish the International Institute of Forensic Studies.
(File RMO2001/0784)
For action or noting by: Dean and Faculty Manager – Law,
Committee Services Officer
8.8 Receipt of Proceedings
Council members were invited to refer to part B of the
Academic Board report and to note the proceedings of the Board. Items
included:
-
new course proposals
-
major amendments to courses
-
Future Directions Report Monash in
Europe – London and Prato (Secretarial note: minute 4.3 Monash in
Europe: London and Prato refers)
-
Other matters considered by Academic
Board
-
The Monash STRIP (Secretarial
note: minutes 4.5 The Monash Science Technology Research and
Innovation Precinct "The Monash STRIP" and item 7.3 Proceedings of
the Resources and Finance Committee refers)
-
Enrolment levels for 2001
-
Quality at Monash: Values and
Principles
-
Guidelines for Academic Review
-
Course Structures for Professional
and Employment needs (Secretarial note: minute 4.4 Course
structures for professional and employment needs refers)
-
Learning and Teaching Plan –
Performance Report 2000
-
Establishment of a Review of Higher
Doctorates
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/113
Council noted the proceedings of meeting 3/2001 of the
Academic Board held on Wednesday, 6 June 2001.
For action or noting by: Secretary to Academic Board
9. Equal Opportunity Committee
9.1 Receipt of Report
A member requested advice as to whether the Admissions
Policy took account of persons disadvantaged by low socio economic
status and Professor Bourke, in his capacity as Chairman, Equal
Opportunity Committee, confirmed that this group was represented in the
policy.
Professor Bourke also informed Council that the
University, in its application to the Equal Opportunity for Women in the
Workplace Agency to assess Monash University in relation to the waiving
requirements under the Equal Opportunity for Women in the Workplace Act
1999, had received advice that Monash had met the requirements for
waiving under the Act and that Monash had been waived from reporting for
a period of two years. Professor Bourke indicated that this represented
a considerable vote of confidence in the Monash program which was seen
to have a positive impact on women in the Monash workplace.
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/114
Council received the report and noted the proceedings of
the Equal Opportunity Committee Meeting 2/2001 held on 4 June 2001.
(File RMO1997/1578)
10. Gippsland Advisory Council
10.1 Receipt of Report
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/115
Council received the report and noted the proceedings of
the Gippsland Advisory Council meeting 2/2001 held on 22 May 2001.
(File RMO1997/0888)
11. General Business
11.1 Senior Appointments
11.1.1 Acceptance of Offers
(Files Personnel)
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/116
Council noted that the following had accepted their
respective offers of appointment and wished to pass on their thanks to
Council:
-
Professor Brian Jolly – Professor of
Medical Education and Director, Centre for Medical and Health Sciences
Education, Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences.
-
Dr David Karoly – Chair of Meteorology,
Faculty of Science.
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/117
Council noted that the following had accepted their
respective offers of appointment approved by the Special Professorial
Appointments Subcommittee of Council:
-
Ms Felicity Hampel – Adjunct Professor,
Faculty of Law.
-
Associate Professor Marilyn Pittard –
Fixed-Term Professor, Faculty of Law.
-
Professor Frank Lawson – Honorary
Professorial Fellow, Faculty of Engineering.
11.1.2 Professor of General Practice – Appointment
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/118
Council approved an offer of appointment as a Professor
of General Practice, Faculty of Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences,
as per the report of the selection committee, be made to the person
named in the document presented.
(File Personnel)
For action or noting by: Dean and Director of Academic
Programs – Medicine, Nursing and Health Sciences, Manager, Senior
Appointments
11.1.3 Chair of Medicinal Chemistry – Appointment
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/119
Council approved an offer of appointment to a Chair of
Medicinal Chemistry and as Head, Department of Medicinal Chemistry,
Faculty of Pharmacy, as per the report of the selection committee, be
made to the person named in the document presented.
(File Personnel)
For action or noting by: Dean and Registrar – Pharmacy,
Manager, Senior Appointments
11.1.4 Chair of Pharmacy Practice – Appointment
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/120
Council approved an offer of appointment to a Chair of
Pharmacy Practice and as Head, Department of Pharmacy Practice, Faculty
of Pharmacy, for a period of five years commencing on a date to be
agreed, as per the report of the selection committee, be made to the
person named in the document presented.
(File Personnel)
For action or noting by: Dean and Registrar – Pharmacy,
Manager, Senior Appointments
11.1.5 The Sir Keith Aickin Chair of Company Law – Appointment (Secretarial
note: minute 8.3.2 of the Report of the Academic Board refers)
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/121
Council approved an offer of appointment to The Sir
Keith Aickin Chair of Company Law, Faculty of Law, be made to the person
named in the document presented.
(File Personnel)
For action or noting by: Dean and Faculty Manager – Law,
Manager, Senior Appointments
11.1.6 Appointment of Selection Committees
(File RMO1997/1623)
11.1.6.1 Chair of Accounting, School of Business and
Economics, Monash South Africa (Secretarial note: minute 8.3.3 of
the Report of the Academic Board refers)
For action or noting by: Dean and Acting Registrar,
Business and Economics, Head of School of Business and Commerce, South
Africa, Manager, Senior Appointments
11.1.6.2 Professor (or Associate Professor) of
Australian Indigenous Studies and Director of the Centre for Australian
Indigenous Studies, Faculty of Arts (Secretarial note: minute
8.3.5 of the Report of the Academic Board refers)
For action or noting by: Dean and Faculty Manager –
Arts, Manager, Senior Appointments
11.1.6.3 Professor of Early Childhood/Primary Education,
Faculty of Education (Secretarial note: minute 8.3.1 of the
Report of the Academic Board refers)
For action or noting by: Dean and Faculty Registrar –
Education, Manager, Senior Appointments
11.1.6.4 Chair of Strategic Business Systems, School of
Business Systems, Faculty of Information Technology (Secretarial
note: minute 8.3.4 of the Report of the Academic Board refers)
For action or noting by: Dean and Acting Faculty Manager
– Information Technology, Manager, Senior Appointments
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/122
Council approved the establishment of the selection
committees for a Chair of Accounting, Professor (or Associate Professor)
of Australian Indigenous Studies and Director of the Centre for
Australian Indigenous Studies, Professor of Early Childhood/Primary
Education and a Chair of Strategic Business Systems as detailed in the
document presented.
11.1.7 Council Nominees to Selection Committees
(RMO1997/1623)
11.1.7.1 Chair of Accounting, Monash South Africa
11.1.7.2 Professor and Head of the School of Business
and Economics, Monash Gippsland
11.1.7.3 Professor (or Associate Professor) of
Australian Indigenous Studies and Director of the Centre for Australian
Indigenous Studies
11.1.7.4 Professor of Early Childhood/Primary Education
11.1.7.5 Chair of Finance
11.1.7.6 Chair of Political Science
11.1.7.7 Chair of Strategic Business Systems
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/123
Council approved the nomination of Council members as
Council’s nominees to the selection committees as detailed in the
document presented.
For action or noting by: Manager, Senior Appointments
11.2 Legislation
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/124
Council made the regulations entitled Faculties
Regulations (Amendment No 1 2001).
(File RMO1999/0213)
For action or noting by: Dean and Acting Faculty Manager
– Information Technology, Committee Services Officer
11.3 Posthumous Master of Arts (Development Studies)
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/125
Council approved the award of a posthumous Master of
Arts (Development Studies) to Mr Damian Leonard Ostrowski.
(File RMO1997/0346)
For action or noting by: Dean and Faculty Manager –
Arts, Manager, Graduations
11.4 Victorian Public Health Research and Education Council Limited
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/126
Council –
(a) approved of Monash University becoming a member of
Victorian Public Health Research and Education Council Limited;
(b) authorised the Vice-Chancellor to sign the
Constitution of the Company on behalf of Monash University as a
subscriber member;
(c) appointed Professor John McNeil as a Director of the
Company;
(d) appointed Professor John McNeil as the
representative of Monash University to attend general meetings of the
Company; and
(e) approved an alteration to the Constitution of the
Company by replacing the word "four" in clause 45 of the Constitution
with the word "two".
(File RMO2000/0327)
For action or noting by: Deputy Vice-Chancellor and
Vice-President (Research and Development), Deputy Vice-Chancellor and
Vice-President (Resources), Professor John McNeil, Faculty of Medicine,
University Solicitor
11.5 Monash University Superannuation Scheme ("M" Scheme)
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/127
1. Council approved the proposed amendments to the
Monash University Superannuation Scheme ("M" Scheme) Trust Deed and
Rules as detailed in the Supplementary Deed presented.
2. Council authorised the affixing of the University
Seal to the Supplementary Deed.
(File RMO1998/2448)
For action or noting by: Deputy Vice-Chancellor and
Vice-President (Resources), Divisional Director, Corporate Finance,
University Solicitor, Ms K Innes, Superannuation Advisor
11.6 Reports on Outside Studies Programs
RESOLUTION CL4/2001/128
Council received and noted OSP reports from the
following staff:
Faculty of Arts
-
Dr Mirna Cicioni, School of European Languages and
Cultures (2000)
-
Associate Professor Naomi White, School of Political
and Social Inquiry (2000)
-
Dr Michael Janover, School of Political and Social
Inquiry (2000)
-
Professor Gary Bouma, School of Political & Social
Inquiry
-
Dr Maryanne Dever, School of Political & Social
Inquiry
-
Associate Professor Peter Fitzpatrick, School of
Literary, Visual and Performance Studies
-
Dr Robin Gerster, School of Literary, Visual &
Performance Studies
-
Professor Clive Probyn, School of Literary, Visual &
Performance Studies
-
Dr Dirk Baltzly, School of Philosophy, Linguistics &
Bioethics
-
Dr Brett Hough, School of Political & Social Inquiry
Faculty of Medicine, Nursing & Health Sciences
-
Ms Elizabeth Grant, School of Nursing
-
Ms Geraldine Milton, School of Nursing
Faculty of Law
(File RMO1999/1608)
11.7 Next Meeting
The next meeting of Council is scheduled to be held at
5.00 pm on Monday, 13 August 2001 at the Clayton Campus. |